Why does tension act downward in this problem?

8 replies · 2K views · last reply
werson tan
Messages
183
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


how to determine the direction of tension ? why it acted in downward direction ? wy not in upward direction ?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Attachments
  • Free-body diagram of a joint with vertical y-axis and horizontal x-axis, showing force FAB = 9.81m pointing up and two cable forces at 45 and 30 degrees drawn downward from the origin, with a red circle around the lower cables.
    7.png
    59.9 KB · Views: 381
Tension and compression are better regarded as pairs of opposite forces rather than as a single force. Which way they act depends on your standpoint. If you pull on a rope, you feel as though the tension is pulling you, but the rope feels as though both ends are pulling on it.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: werson tan
haruspex said:
Tension and compression are better regarded as pairs of opposite forces rather than as a single force. Which way they act depends on your standpoint. If you pull on a rope, you feel as though the tension is pulling you, but the rope feels as though both ends are pulling on it.
well, i still dotn understand , can you explain based on the question ?
 
werson tan said:
well, i still dotn understand , can you explain based on the question ?
The tensions in BC, BD act upward on the girder at C and D but downward on the junction B.
 
haruspex said:
The tensions in BC, BD act upward on the girder at C and D but downward on the junction B.
why they will act downward on the junction B.
 
werson tan said:
why they will act downward on the junction B.
Imagine yourself as junction B, i.e. you are holding the two wires BC and BD, and holding a third wire going up to some support above you. You alone are holding it all together. Are the wires BC and BD pulling you down or pushing you up?
 
haruspex said:
Imagine yourself as junction B, i.e. you are holding the two wires BC and BD, and holding a third wire going up to some support above you. You alone are holding it all together. Are the wires BC and BD pulling you down or pushing you up?
yes
 
werson tan said:
yes
tats how the direction of tension it is ?