Why does U in complement of A∪A' imply A∪A' is closed?

4 replies · 3K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
TL;DR
I am reading Tej Bahadur Singh: Elements of Topology, CRC Press, 2013 and am focused on the notions of limit points and closure in a topological space ... and I need help with understanding Singh's proof of Theorem 1.3.7 ...
I am reading Tej Bahadur Singh: Elements of Topology, CRC Press, 2013 ... ... and am currently focused on Chapter 1, Section 1.2: Topological Spaces ...

I need help in order to fully understand Singh's proof of Theorem 1.3.7 ... (using only the definitions and results Singh has established to date ... see below ... )

Theorem 1.3.7 reads as follows:
Printed text of Theorem 1.3.7: Let A be a subset of a space X. Then the closure of A equals A union A', where A' is the derived set of A.

Printed proof from a topology textbook: if x is neither a point nor a limit point of A, an open neighbourhood U of x misses A, so A union A' is closed and the closure of A is contained in A union A', with A union A' contained in the closure of A.


In the above proof by Singh we read the following:

" ... ... So ##U## is contained in the complement of ##A \cup A'##, and hence ##A \cup A'## is closed. It follows that ##\overline{A} \subseteq A \cup A'## ... ... "My question is as follows:

Why does ##U## being contained in the complement of ##A \cup A'## imply that ##A \cup A'## is closed ... and further why then does it follow that ##\overline{A} \subseteq A \cup A'## ... ... Help will be appreciated ...

Peter==========================================================================================It is important that any proof of the above remarks only rely on the definitions and results Singh has established to date ... namely Definition 1.3.3, Proposition 1.3.4, Theorem 1.3.5 and Definition 1.3.6 ... which read as follows ... :
Text from Definition 1.3.3: Let X be a space and A ⊆ X. The set closure of A equals the intersection of all sets F that are closed in X and contain A, which is the smallest closed set containing A, called the closure of A, denoted cl(A). A point x in the closure of A is an adherent point of A.

Textbook page with Proposition 1.3.4 on closures (parts a to d), Theorem 1.3.5 with proof, and Definition 1.3.6 of limit points and the derived set, with a handwritten note 'A' near the definition.

Hope that helps ...

Peter
 
Let ##Z=A\cup A'.## Showing that every element of ##X\setminus Z## has an open neighborhood disjoint from ##Z## means that ##X\setminus Z## is open, that is, ##Z## is closed.

For your second question, we know ##A\subseteq A\cup A'##. Taking closures of both sides gives ##\overline{A}\subseteq \overline{A\cup A'}=A\cup A.'## I am using the fact that if ##B\subseteq C,## then ##\overline{B}\subseteq\overline{C}.##
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
Infrared said:
Let ##Z=A\cup A'.## Showing that every element of ##X\setminus Z## has an open neighborhood disjoint from ##Z## means that ##X\setminus Z## is open, that is, ##Z## is closed.

For your second question, we know ##A\subseteq A\cup A'##. Taking closures of both sides gives ##\overline{A}\subseteq \overline{A\cup A'}=A\cup A.'## I am using the fact that if ##B\subseteq C,## then ##\overline{B}\subseteq\overline{C}.##
Thanks for the help Infrared ... but can you help further ...

In showing ##Z=A\cup A'## is closed you write ... "Showing that every element of ##X\setminus Z## has an open neighborhood disjoint from ##Z## means that ##X\setminus Z## is open, that is, ##Z## is closed."

Can you explain homework this follows from the definitions and results Singh has established to date (which are Definition 1.3.3, Proposition 1.3.4, Theorem 1.3.5 and Definition 1.3.6 details of which are shown in my post ... note that the only relevant definitions and results Singh has established up to this point are the definition of a topology ... and hence an open set ... and the definition of a neighbourhood ... )

Hope you can help further ...

Peter
 
The argument you quoted shows that for every ##x\in X\setminus Z##, there is an open set ##U_x\subset X\setminus Z## that contains ##x##. So we can write ##X\setminus Z=\bigcup_{x\in X\setminus Z} U_x.## This is a union of open sets, so ##X\setminus Z## is open. This means ##Z## is closed.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
Thanks Infrared ...

Really appreciate your help...

Peter