Why does Wien's displacement law not hold for frequency?

3 replies · 6K views · last reply
Jezuz
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
Wien's displacement law states that the wavelength of highest intensity in the radiation from a blackbody is something like:

[tex]\lambda_{max} = \frac{2.898*10^{-3}}{T}[/tex]

in meters, where T is the temperature given in kelvins.

If you try to transform this law into frequency one would expect that we should have:

[tex]f_{max} = \frac{c}{\lambda_{max}}[/tex]

but apparently this is not the case! Why is it like that?
I mean, if you have a blackbody radiation field it will have a maximum of intensity at some frequency, but shouldn't that frequency coincide with the wavelength for which it has the maximum intensity?

Please help!
 
Wein's law results from finding a maximum in the Planck distribution [itex]u \left( \lambda \right)[/itex]. Given [itex]u \left( \lambda \right)[/itex] and [itex]\lambda \left( f \right) = c/f[/itex], a new function [itex]\tilde{u} \left( f \right) = u \left( \lambda \left( f \right) \right)[/itex] of frequency can be defined, but [itex]\tilde{u} \left( f \right)[/itex] is not the Planck distribution in the frequency domain. If it were, then [itex]f_{max}[/itex] and [itex]\lambda_{max}[/itex] would correspond.

[tex]\int_{0}^{\infty} u \left( \lambda \right) d\lambda = \int_{\infty}^{0} \tilde{u} \left( f \right) \frac{d \lambda}{df} df = - \int_{0}^{\infty} \tilde{u} \left( f \right) \frac{d \lambda}{df} df[/tex]

Consequently,

[tex]- \tilde{u} \left( f \right) \frac{d \lambda}{df}[/tex]

needs to be maximized to find [itex]f_{max}[/itex].

Regards,
George
 
Last edited:
Of course!
You need to have the two integrals you wrote equall so that the energy (intensity) that is radiated in a certain frequency range is the same as the intensity of the corresponding wavelength, right?
 
Jezuz said:
Of course!
You need to have the two integrals you wrote equall so that the energy (intensity) that is radiated in a certain frequency range is the same as the intensity of the corresponding wavelength, right?

Yes.

Note that I corrected a silly mistake in my previous post.

Regards,
George