Why does Z have a universal mapping property in tensor product existence?

4 replies · 3K views · last reply
Math Amateur
Gold Member
MHB
Messages
3,920
Reaction score
48
I am reading Bruce N. Coopersteins book: Advanced Linear Algebra (Second Edition) ... ...

I am focused on Section 10.1 Introduction to Tensor Products ... ...

I need help with another aspect of the proof of Theorem 10.1 regarding the existence of a tensor product ... ...The relevant part of Theorem 10.1 reads as follows:
Printed textbook page showing Theorem 10.1 on the existence of the tensor product of vector spaces V1 through Vm over a field F, followed by its proof constructing the quotient space V = Z/U and a multilinear map gamma.

Handwritten-style proof notes on linear algebra: part (1) on the equality of gamma with scalar multiplication, equations (10.1) and (10.2), and the vector-space zero conditions for gamma and the coset U in part (2).

Handwritten-style proof text from a linear algebra textbook showing equations (10.3) through (10.7), ending with f((v1,...,vi-1,cvi,vi+1,...,vm)) - cf(v1,...,vm) = 0_W, with a note that the equality holds because f is multilinear.

In the above text we read the following:" ... ... Recall that [itex]V_1 \times \ ... \ \times V_m = X[/itex] and that [itex]Z[/itex] is a vector space based on [itex]X[/itex]. Since [itex]W[/itex] is a vector space and [itex]f[/itex] is a map from [itex]X[/itex] to [itex]W[/itex], by the universal property of [itex]Z[/itex] there exists a unique linear transformation [itex]S \ : \ Z \longrightarrow W[/itex] such that [itex]S[/itex] restricted to [itex]X[/itex] is [itex]f[/itex]. ... ..."Now I have summarised the mappings involved in Theorem 10.1 in Figure 1 below ... ...

Commutative diagram labelled Figure 1: X = V1 x V2 x ... x Vm maps by i to Z and by f to W; gamma maps X to V = Z/U; S maps Z to W; T maps V to W.
My question is as follows:

Why does [itex]Z[/itex] have a universal mapping property ...? ... ... and indeed if [itex]Z[/itex] has one, why doesn't [itex]V[/itex] ... ... giving us the relationship [itex]T \gamma = f[/itex] that we want ... what is special about [itex]Z[/itex]?
Hope someone can help ...

Peter

*** NOTE ***

... ... oh no! ... ... I think I have just realized the answer to my question ... hmm ... embarrassingly simple ... ... I think that [itex]Z[/itex] has a UMP because [itex]( Z, \iota )[/itex] is assumed to be the vector space based on the set [itex]X[/itex]... and vector spaces based on a set have a UMP ... is that right? ... see Cooperstein Definition 10.1 on the first page of Section 10.1 provided below ...

Can someone confirm that this is the reason Z has a Universal Mapping Property ...

Peter
==========================================================*** NOTE ***It may help readers of the above post to be able to read Cooperstein's introduction to Section 10.1 where he covers, among other things, the notion of a vector space being based on a set and the idea of the universal mapping problem ... ... so I am providing this text as follows:
Page from a linear algebra textbook titled Introduction to Tensor Products, showing Definition 10.1 of a vector space based on a set and a diagram for the universal mapping problem with maps i, j and T between X, V and W.

Handwritten-style printed page of a textbook solution: a diagram of a map i from X to V and a map T from V to W, with a map j from X to W, followed by proof text about vector spaces and linear transformations.

Typeset page of Section 10.1 on tensor products: Definition 10.2 of a tensor product (V, γ), Remark 10.1, Notation, and Lemma 10.1 with its proof, using multilinear maps and linear transformations.

Handwritten-style proof page from a linear algebra text defining the vector space Z on X = V_1 x ... x V_m, with the quotient map gamma and the subspace U.
 
Attachments
  • Printed page from a linear algebra textbook showing Theorem 10.1 on the existence of the tensor product of vector spaces V1 through Vm over F, followed by its proof constructing a quotient space Z/U and a multilinear map gamma.
    Cooperstein - 1 - Theorem 10.1 - PART 1 ....png
    36.5 KB · Views: 1,073
  • Handwritten-style proof notes on linear algebra: properties 1 and 2 defining the map gamma on V_1 through V_m, with equations (10.1) and (10.2), followed by derivation steps reducing the equalities to membership in U.
    Cooperstein - 2 - Theorem 10.1 - PART 2 ....png
    29.4 KB · Views: 783
  • Handwritten-style printed proof page from linear algebra text showing steps of a tensor product existence proof, with equations (10.3) to (10.7) using the linearity of S and multilinearity of f.
    Cooperstein - 3 - Theorem 10.1 - PART 3 ....png
    37.9 KB · Views: 930
  • Commutative diagram labelled Figure 1: X = V1 x V2 x ... x Vm maps by i to Z, by f to W, by gamma to V = Z/U; S maps Z to W and T maps V to W, with Tgamma = f.
    Figure 1 - Cooperstein - Theorem 10.1 - Mappings.png
    18.6 KB · Views: 1,053
  • Page from a linear algebra textbook introducing tensor products, with Definition 10.1 on vector spaces based on a set and Figure 10.1 showing a triangular diagram of maps from X to V and W.
    Cooperstein - 1 - Section 10.1 - PART 1 ....png
    70.8 KB · Views: 727
  • Handwritten-style printed page of a linear algebra proof showing a diagram with points X, V and W, arrows labelled i, j and T, and dense mathematical text about vector spaces and linear maps.
    Cooperstein - 2 - Section 10.1 - PART 2 ....png
    38.4 KB · Views: 637
  • Textbook page showing the definition of a tensor product of vector spaces, Definition 10.2, Remark 10.1, notation for composition, and Lemma 10.1 with its proof.
    Cooperstein - 3 - Section 10.1 - PART 3 ....png
    35.3 KB · Views: 718
  • Printed page of Section 10.1 on tensor products, showing the proof of Theorem 10.1 with definitions of vector space Z based on the product set X and the quotient space V.
    Cooperstein - 4 - Section 10.1 - PART 4 ....png
    33.1 KB · Views: 702
Last edited:
I think a helpful thing to know/understand is the concept of maps factoring through (the quotient, here): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mathematical_jargon in algebra, there are conditions on the kernel of a map. Factoring through is in analogy with the factoring of numbers as products.

You are given functions f:A-->C , g: A-->B . Then f factors through g if there is an h: with f=hg ; h is a map from B-->C. This is I think the clearest way of understanding the tensor product. For vector spaces V,W , the tensor product , ## V \ Oline W ## is a vector space in which every bilinear map defined on VxW into a third vector space Z factors through a linear map from the tensor product into Z. The conditions on the kernel guarantee that maps factor through. I will look up the conditions on the kernel and image of the respective groups and get back with it.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Math Amateur
Thanks WWGD ... most helpful ...

Peter
 
Math Amateur said:
Thanks WWGD ... most helpful ...

Peter
Glad it helped, Peter, I went through my own pain trying to understand it -- I feel your pain :).
 
Thanks again WWGD ... good to have your support ...

Peter
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: WWGD