Why is momentum conserved in cases of linear and angular motion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter VHAHAHA
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Concept Momentum
Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around the conservation of momentum in both linear and angular motion, specifically in scenarios involving explosions and collisions. Participants explore the conditions under which momentum is conserved, questioning the impact of external forces such as gravity during these events.

Discussion Character

  • Conceptual clarification, Assumption checking

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants discuss two cases: the explosion of a bomb and the collision of a putty wad with a rotating system. They question how momentum can be conserved despite the presence of external forces like gravity.

Discussion Status

Some participants suggest that the time interval during which the forces act is so short that the effects of gravity can be neglected, leading to conservation of momentum. Others explore the implications of this "impulse approximation" in the context of the problems presented.

Contextual Notes

Participants note the importance of considering the time scale of events when evaluating the effects of external forces on momentum conservation. There is an ongoing exploration of the definitions and assumptions related to momentum in dynamic systems.

VHAHAHA
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
i sometimes don't know why momentum is conserved is these cases(for both linear and angular), i know that for momentum to conserve , external net force(linear) or external net torque should be zero
can someone please help me with the following two condition??
Case1
A bomb is projected to the mid air, and then exploded in the mid air and two fragments are formed
we have
(Mass of the bomb)( velocity before explosion) = (Mass of fragment 1 )( V of F1) + (M of fragment 2 ) ( V of F2)
Why?? i think there is a external force acting on the bomb and it is Mg ? after explosion there are also m1g and m2g acting on the fragments respectively? why conserved? the net force is not zero

Case2
In fact it is a question that was asked in this forum before, but i dun understand the concept
Two balls of mass 2.26 kg are attached to the ends of a thin rod of negligible mass and length 72 cm. The rod is free to rotate without friction about a horizontal axis through its center. A putty wad of mass 145 g drops onto one of the balls, with a speed 2.7 m/s, and sticks to it. What is the angular speed of the system just after the putty wad hits?

Why the angular momentum conserved just b4 and after collision ? there is a external non zero net force acting on system that is the weight of the putty wad?

i know how to do these question but i dun know the concept, can anyone help
 
Physics news on Phys.org
VHAHAHA said:
A bomb is projected to the mid air, and then exploded in the mid air and two fragments are formed we have
(Mass of the bomb)( velocity before explosion) = (Mass of fragment 1 )( V of F1) + (M of fragment 2 ) ( V of F2)
Why?? i think there is a external force acting on the bomb and it is Mg ?
Change in momentum due to a force is the integral of the force wrt time. Immediately after the explosion, no time has elapsed, so gravity has not had time to change the momentum.
 
VHAHAHA said:
i sometimes don't know why momentum is conserved is these cases(for both linear and angular), i know that for momentum to conserve , external net force(linear) or external net torque should be zero
can someone please help me with the following two condition??
Case1
A bomb is projected to the mid air, and then exploded in the mid air and two fragments are formed
we have
(Mass of the bomb)( velocity before explosion) = (Mass of fragment 1 )( V of F1) + (M of fragment 2 ) ( V of F2)
Why?? i think there is a external force acting on the bomb and it is Mg ? after explosion there are also m1g and m2g acting on the fragments respectively? why conserved? the net force is not zero
You would be correct if you were being asked what the momentum of the bomb fragments was some time after the explosion. But if the question is just asking you for the total momentum immediately before and immediately after the explosion, total momentum would not change. The change in momentum from gravity is Force x time through which the force acts. If that time interval is arbitrarily small enough, gravity does not add significant momentum.

Case2
In fact it is a question that was asked in this forum before, but i dun understand the concept
Two balls of mass 2.26 kg are attached to the ends of a thin rod of negligible mass and length 72 cm. The rod is free to rotate without friction about a horizontal axis through its center. A putty wad of mass 145 g drops onto one of the balls, with a speed 2.7 m/s, and sticks to it. What is the angular speed of the system just after the putty wad hits?

Why the angular momentum conserved just b4 and after collision ? there is a external non zero net force acting on system that is the weight of the putty wad?
What is the angular momentum of the putty wad relative to the axis of rotation immediately before the wad strikes the ball? (hint: you have to know the angle of its velocity to the rod at the time of impact). Add that angular momentum to the angular momentum of the rod/ball system. That is the total angular momentum immediately before the collision. Assume the impact occurs over a very short time interval. What is the angular momentum immediately after the impact. (remember again, if you make the time interval small enough, the torque due to gravity will not add significant angular momentum [itex]\Delta L = \tau\Delta t[/itex]).

AM
 
Last edited:
i see
it means that the time for ch is very short so that effect of gravity can be neglected
right ? thx
 
This is what we call the "impulse approximation". The collision forces act over a very short interval - and so their magnitudes are very very large, making external forces such as gravity negligible.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 71 ·
3
Replies
71
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 17 ·
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
335
Views
17K
Replies
10
Views
3K
Replies
23
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K