What HallsofIvy said is true, but I think it's not quite the point of the question.
The Cayley-Hamilton theorem says that the matrix ##A## satisfies its own characteristic equation. For an ##n \times n## matrix, the characteristic equation is of order ##n##, so ##A^n## is a linear combination of ##I, A, \dots, A^{n-1}##. It follows that every power ##A^k## where ##k > n## is also a linear combination of the first ##n-1## powers.
For A ##2 \times 2## matrix, that means every power of ##A## is a linear combination of ##A## and ##I##. That is true even if the eigenvectors are not independent, and you can't diagonalize ##A##.