Why Is the Constant Excluded in Uncertainty Calculations?

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter elitewarr
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Constant
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
3 replies · 3K views
elitewarr
Messages
62
Reaction score
0
For a question like In an experiment, the external diameter D and internal diameter d of a metal tube were found to be (64 +/- 2) mm and (47 +/- 1) mm respectively. What is the maximum percentage error for the cross-sectional area of the metal tube?

I will need to find the external area.
So, area = pi(1/2d)^2
But I'm confused over whether should the uncertainty change?
What I mean was 1/2(64 +/- 2) = (32 +/- 1) ??
Or will the uncertainty remain at 2? If it remains at 2, the percentage uncertainty will definitely change.

And why does the formula R=kAB, k is a constant and A and B are physical terms, has the uncertainty formula tR / R = tA / A + tB / B
where tR / R, tA / A, tB / B are fractional uncertainty.
Why is the constant excluded?
R = kAB = AB + AB + AB ... + AB
So won't the uncertainty add up?

Thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


elitewarr said:
But I'm confused over whether should the uncertainty change?
What I mean was 1/2(64 +/- 2) = (32 +/- 1)
Yes. X = 64 +/- 2 means we are sure that X is between 62 and 66, which is equivalent to saying X/2 is between 31 and 33, hence X = 32 +/- 1. Multiplication by a constant always preserves relative error.

And why does the formula R=kAB, k is a constant and A and B are physical terms, has the uncertainty formula tR / R = tA / A + tB / B
where tR / R, tA / A, tB / B are fractional uncertainty.
Why is the constant excluded?
R = kAB = AB + AB + AB ... + AB
So won't the uncertainty add up?
The absolute uncertainty adds up. The relative uncertainty is unchanged since
[tex]\frac{\Delta R}{R} = \frac{k \Delta(AB)}{k AB} = \frac{\Delta(AB)}{AB}[/tex]
 


Ok. Thanks for clearing up things.

"Multiplication by a constant always preserves relative error"

This is also due to the constant being canceled right?
 


elitewarr said:
Ok. Thanks for clearing up things.

"Multiplication by a constant always preserves relative error"

This is also due to the constant being canceled right?

Yes, that's right.