MHB Why is zero not included in the interval (0, infinity)?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Casio1
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Functions
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the exclusion of zero from the interval notation (0, infinity) and the inclusion of zero in [0, infinity) for the function g(x) = sqrt(x). Participants clarify that parentheses indicate an open interval where the endpoint is not included, while square brackets denote a closed interval where the endpoint is included. The confusion arises from the interpretation of intervals and the fact that the domain of h(x) = 1/x is R excluding 0, represented as two open intervals: (-infinity, 0) and (0, infinity). Ultimately, the distinction between open and closed intervals is crucial for understanding why zero is not part of (0, infinity).
Casio1
Messages
86
Reaction score
0
g(x) = sqrt x

Because x in the rule is square root on the right hand side I can understand why only a positive number would be allowed in the left hand side value of x.

I undertand that because x cannot be less than 0, but the square root of x can be any positive number, then the interval notation I understand would be [0, infinity)

zero because x cannot be less than 0, and infinity because x can be any other number.

OK, this is where I have a problem understanding.

h(x) = 1/x

x cannot be zero, the function h has domain R excluding 0, I am to understand this consists of two open intervals.

I understand that x can be any negative number, but am failing to understand why 0 is then included, the interval is written as ( - infinity, 0)

I am told that R excludes 0, so then how can the open interval include (0, infinity).

I understand the infinity part, but x cannot be zero so where does that arrive in the interval?

Please advise if you can.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
Casio said:
g(x) = sqrt x
Because x in the rule is square root on the right hand side I can understand why only a positive number would be allowed in the left hand side value of x.
I undertand that because x cannot be less than 0, but the square root of x can be any positive number, then the interval notation I understand would be [0, infinity)
zero because x cannot be less than 0, and infinity because x can be any other number.
OK, this is where I have a problem understanding.
h(x) = 1/x
x cannot be zero, the function h has domain R excluding 0, I am to understand this consists of two open intervals.
I understand that x can be any negative number, but am failing to understand why 0 is then included, the interval is written as ( - infinity, 0)
I am told that R excludes 0, so then how can the open interval include (0, infinity).
I understand the infinity part, but x cannot be zero so where does that arrive in the interval?
Please advise if you can.
$(-\infty)\cup(0,\infty)$
 
Casio said:
g(x) = sqrt x

Because x in the rule is square root on the right hand side I can understand why only a positive number would be allowed in the left hand side value of x.

I undertand that because x cannot be less than 0, but the square root of x can be any positive number, then the interval notation I understand would be [0, infinity)

zero because x cannot be less than 0, and infinity because x can be any other number.

OK, this is where I have a problem understanding.

h(x) = 1/x

x cannot be zero, the function h has domain R excluding 0, I am to understand this consists of two open intervals.

I understand that x can be any negative number, but am failing to understand why 0 is then included, the interval is written as ( - infinity, 0)

I am told that R excludes 0, so then how can the open interval include (0, infinity).

I understand the infinity part, but x cannot be zero so where does that arrive in the interval?

Please advise if you can.
I think that you are maybe failing to notice the difference between [0, infinity) and (0, infinity). A square bracket means that the endpoint is included in the interval (as in a closed interval), but a parenthesis means that the endpoint is excluded (as in an open interval). To be precise, (0, infinity) means the set of all numbers x such that 0<x<infinity. The strict inequality means that 0 is not included in the interval.
 
Opalg said:
I think that you are maybe failing to notice the difference between [0, infinity) and (0, infinity). A square bracket means that the endpoint is included in the interval (as in a closed interval), but a parenthesis means that the endpoint is excluded (as in an open interval). To be precise, (0, infinity) means the set of all numbers x such that 0<x<infinity. The strict inequality means that 0 is not included in the interval.

I am sorry I have probably not explained the misunderstanding too well:o

h(x) = 1/x

if h(0) = 1/0, then this would not be allowed, thus anything divided by zero = 0

I am told that the function h has domain R excluding 0, which consists of two open intervals (- infinity, 0) and (0, infinity)

I understand the parenthesis, they are open intervals, and I understand the - infinity as the x value can be any negative number up to 0.

The confusion is that I am told it excludes 0 yet 0 is included in the parenthesis indicating to me that the interval finishes at 0, then starts at 0 again to infinity, yet the question says R excludes 0.

That is what I am confused about?
 
Casio said:
The confusion is that I am told it excludes 0 yet 0 is included in the parenthesis indicating to me that the interval finishes at 0, then starts at 0 again to infinity, yet the question says R excludes 0.
What exactly do you mean by "0 is included in the parenthesis" and "the interval finishes at 0"?
 
Casio said:
I am sorry I have probably not explained the misunderstanding too well:o

I suggest you read Opalg's reply again, very carefully. I believe he addresses the source of your confusion. The parentheses indicate that we are to include all numbers up to, but not including 0. So no matter how close you get to zero, the number is included in the domain, until you get to zero itself. \((0, \infty)\) would, for example, include numbers like 0.0000001, or \(10^{-50}\), or really any real number strictly greater than zero.

You may then wonder, perhaps, why in our notation we write the interval as starting from 0 instead of starting from the "next" number after zero. The answer is that there is no such number. No matter what positive number you come up with, it is always possible to find a smaller one. So we use zero as the boundary, with the understanding that zero itself is not to be included.
 
Suppose ,instead of the usual x,y coordinate system with an I basis vector along the x -axis and a corresponding j basis vector along the y-axis we instead have a different pair of basis vectors ,call them e and f along their respective axes. I have seen that this is an important subject in maths My question is what physical applications does such a model apply to? I am asking here because I have devoted quite a lot of time in the past to understanding convectors and the dual...
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. In Dirac’s Principles of Quantum Mechanics published in 1930 he introduced a “convenient notation” he referred to as a “delta function” which he treated as a continuum analog to the discrete Kronecker delta. The Kronecker delta is simply the indexed components of the identity operator in matrix algebra Source: https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/what-exactly-is-diracs-delta-function/ by...
Back
Top