Greetings all. I hope it's OK to post here. My issue here is with the theory and not with the actual algebra or calculus.(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

I understand this calculus question on parametric curves except why there must be a double root instead of just a repeated root in the last part. Please see the red question mark below.

I understand that for the values of [itex] t [/itex] on curve C which two normals can be drawn to, the equation [itex]0=at^3 - th + 2at-k[/itex] will have two roots. But why must these roots be identical and so repeated?

Thank you all.

Original question

[itex]\boxed{\text{Recall that }{{x}^{3}}+px+q=0\text{ has exactly one real solution if }p\ge 0. \\

\text{A parabola }C\text{ is given parametrically by }x=a{{t}^{2}},\text{ }y=2at\text{ (}a>0). \\

\text{Find an equation which must be satisfied by }t\text{ at points on }C\text{ at which the normal } \\

\text{passes through }(h,k).\text{ Hence show that if }h\le 2a\text{, exactly one normal to }C\text{ will pass through }(h,k). \\

\\

\text{Find, in Cartesian form, the equation of the locus of the points from which exactly two normals can be drawn to }C.} [/itex]

Original solution

[itex] y = 2at, x = at^2 \text{ so } \dot{y} = 2a, \dot{x} = 2at \implies \displaystyle -1/\frac{dy}{dx} = -t[/itex]. Therefore the equation of a normal will be [itex]\displaystyle \frac{y - 2at}{x-at^2} = -t \iff y = -t x + at^3+2at[/itex]

therefore we have [itex]0=at^3 - th + 2at-k[/itex]. By considering the coefficient of t, for there to be one solution [itex]2a -h \ge 0 \Longleftrightarrow 2a \ge h[/itex]

[itex]0=at^3 - th + 2at-k[/itex] if two normals can be drawn then we have a repeated root.(?)

Therefore [itex]3at^2 +(2a-h)=0 \implies \displaystyle t = \pm \sqrt{\frac{h-2a}{3a}}[/itex]

So [itex]\pm \sqrt{\frac{h-2a}{3a}} \left ( a \left ( \frac{h-2a}{3a} \right ) + 2a - h \right ) -k =0 \implies \displaystyle k^2 = \frac{4(h-2a)^3}{27a}[/itex]

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Why Repeated Roots instead of Two Distinct Roots

**Physics Forums | Science Articles, Homework Help, Discussion**