Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Sushmit Nandy
  • Start date
91 replies · 3K views · last reply
PeterDonis said:
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence


Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.


You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.


This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.


The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard GR.

PeterDonis said:
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence


Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.


You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.


This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.


The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard

PeterDonis said:
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence


Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.


You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.


This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.


The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard GR.
PeterDonis said:
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence


Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.


You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.


This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.


The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard GR.

PeterDonis said:
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence


Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.


You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.


This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.


The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard GR.
But Mach's principle is then violated. Does that mean that standard GR is not Machian. Is there any non-fringe modern theories which obey Mach's principle strictly but give the same predictions as standard GR ?
 
PeterDonis said:
No, it is not.

In the original scenario, the box has nonzero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has zero vorticity. This scenario can be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime, as we have been discussing.

In your revised scenario, the box has zero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has nonzero vorticity. This scenario is measurably different than the first, because vorticity can be measured. It also cannot be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime; the spacetime geometry would have to be something like the Godel universe.


If your intent in restricting measurements to only rulers and clocks is to rule out accelerometers and vorticity measurements, then your intent is wrong. "Equivalent" doesn't mean "rulers and clocks agree" if you don't allow other observables to be measured using rulers and clocks. "Equivalent" means all observables agree, and that has to include anything that is an invariant.


Because they are different scenarios. See above.


I'm not sure what you mean here, and your use of "the principle of sufficient reason" has already been questioned in this thread. If you can find a reference that discusses how to apply this principle in physics and why it matters, please give it. Otherwise we will need to stick with mainstream physics as it's presented in textbooks and peer-reviewed papers.
Sir this is what I found. It's the paper "The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity" by A. Einstein. Please refer to section 2: "The need for an extension of the postulate of relativity". Here I think this problem has been discussed. The link is:
1916 - The Foundation of The General Theory of Relativity (Einstein) on Scribd