Why rotation apparently seems to be absolute?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Sushmit Nandy
  • Start date
103 replies · 4K views · last reply
PeterDonis said:
It is a part of the kinematic decomposition of the congruence of worldlines describing the object. @Matterwave gave the basic math in post #43. Also see this Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congr...atical_decomposition_of_a_timelike_congruence


Yes, that is a prediction of a congruence with nonzero vorticity in flat spacetime.


You don't need anything external, unless you want to call the spacetime geometry itself "external". The vorticity is a property of the box itself and the spacetime geometry it's embedded in.


This is physics. We don't "think" something without doing the math. If you do the math, you will see that it predicts what the rest of us have been saying, and not what you have been saying.


The inertial forces are due to the spacetime geometry and the properties of the congruence of worldlines that describes the box. To the extent that the spacetime geometry is determined by other matter in the universe, it has an effect, yes. This is standard GR.
But Mach's principle is then violated. Does that mean that standard GR is not Machian. Is there any non-fringe modern theories which obey Mach's principle strictly but give the same predictions as standard GR ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
PeterDonis said:
No, it is not.

In the original scenario, the box has nonzero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has zero vorticity. This scenario can be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime, as we have been discussing.

In your revised scenario, the box has zero vorticity and the rest of the matter in the universe has nonzero vorticity. This scenario is measurably different than the first, because vorticity can be measured. It also cannot be realized in flat Minkowski spacetime; the spacetime geometry would have to be something like the Godel universe.


If your intent in restricting measurements to only rulers and clocks is to rule out accelerometers and vorticity measurements, then your intent is wrong. "Equivalent" doesn't mean "rulers and clocks agree" if you don't allow other observables to be measured using rulers and clocks. "Equivalent" means all observables agree, and that has to include anything that is an invariant.


Because they are different scenarios. See above.


I'm not sure what you mean here, and your use of "the principle of sufficient reason" has already been questioned in this thread. If you can find a reference that discusses how to apply this principle in physics and why it matters, please give it. Otherwise we will need to stick with mainstream physics as it's presented in textbooks and peer-reviewed papers.
Sir this is what I found. It's the paper "The Foundation of the General Theory of Relativity" by A. Einstein. Please refer to section 2: "The need for an extension of the postulate of relativity". Here I think this problem has been discussed. The link is:
1916 - The Foundation of The General Theory of Relativity (Einstein) on Scribd
 
PeterDonis said:
Note that the Godel universe does not rotate the entire universe about a "point". But it is a spacetime geometry in which the entire universe can be said to be "rotating".
Yeah, I should have quoted the relevant part of OPs post I was responding to:

Sushmit Nandy said:
Imagine we reverse the scenario, the box remains as it is and we rotate all the matter in the universe around the box at the same speed.

The Godel universe has uniform vorticity throughout space time. Anywhere you stand, the matter rotates around you. It's somewhat different than what OP is picturing here imo. It's also quite pathological since there's CTCs (based) at every point as well.
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
Does that mean that standard GR is not Machian.
Yes, standard GR is not Machian. And experimental evidence shows that the universe is non-Machian in the same way that GR is.

Sushmit Nandy said:
Is there any non-fringe modern theories which obey Mach's principle strictly but give the same predictions as standard GR ?
The main candidate is Brans Dicke gravity. It has a free parameter ##\omega##. When ##\omega \approx 1## the universe is Machian, and when ##\omega = \infty## you get GR. Current evidence places a lower bound of ##\omega = 40000## with no upper bound.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
Sushmit Nandy said:
Mach's principle is then violated.
As I think has already been commented in this thread, that is a matter of some debate in the GR community.

Sushmit Nandy said:
Does that mean that standard GR is not Machian.
Some physicists think so, some don't. That's not a question that we're going to resolve here; it's a matter of philosophy, not physics. Nature doesn't care about "principles" that humans (or at least some of them) think are important.

Sushmit Nandy said:
Is there any non-fringe modern theories which obey Mach's principle strictly but give the same predictions as standard GR ?
There are no other "modern theories" period that I know of that give exactly the same predictions as standard GR under all conditions.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
Dale said:
standard GR is not Machian
As I said, I think this is a matter of some debate in the GR community. As one example of the view that GR is Machian, see the monograph Gravitation and Inertia by Cuifolini and Wheeler.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
I
PeterDonis said:
As I said, I think this is a matter of some debate in the GR community. As one example of the view that GR is Machian, see the monograph Gravitation and Inertia by Cuifolini and Wheeler.
I think Shape Dynamics by Julian Barbour conforms to Mach's principle. Just found it on Wikipedia and so thought of sharing it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_dynamics
 
Matterwave said:
The Godel universe has uniform vorticity throughout space time. Anywhere you stand, the matter rotates around you.
More precisely, this is true for the congruence of worldlines that has constant spatial coordinates in the standard coordinate chart for Godel spacetime. But it is quite possible to find a different congruence that has zero vorticity and could describe the non-rotating box. And for this congruence, the rest of the universe is still "rotating around you".

However, there is also something very counterintuitive about this: the "rotating" (nonzero vorticity) congruence, with constant spatial coordinates, has zero proper acceleration (i.e., free fall, a geodesic congruence)--and the "non-rotating" (zero vorticity) congruence, that would describe the box, has nonzero proper acceleration!

See this thread for more discussion:


Matterwave said:
It's somewhat different than what OP is picturing here imo.
"What OP is picturing" has to be matched to some actual valid solution of the Einstein Field Equation; otherwise we have no way of analyzing it at all. I am not aware of any other such solution that can be used in this case. In particular, I am not aware of any solution in which the box has zero vorticity, the rest of the universe has nonzero vorticity, but the box is in free fall and the rest of the universe is accelerated.
 
PeterDonis said:
As I said, I think this is a matter of some debate in the GR community. As one example of the view that GR is Machian, see the monograph Gravitation and Inertia by Cuifolini and Wheeler.
Yes. This is largely a debate about what “Machian” means. Mach never actually proposed a theory and his statement is very vague. So people can and do “move the goalposts” to prolong the debate.

One thing is clear: Brans and Dicke intended their theory to fix what they understood as the non-Machian aspects of GR.
 
Dale said:
Yes. This is largely a debate about what “Machian” means. Mach never actually proposed a theory and his statement is very vague. So people can and do “move the goalposts” to prolong the debate.

One thing is clear: Brans and Dicke intended their theory to fix what they understood as the non-Machian aspects of GR.
Sorry sir, but I didn't mean to "prolong" the debate. I just wanted to ask a genuine question which I had in my mind, namely the rotating box in an empty universe. I didn't mean to argue. And if that's the case, then it would be great if someone can tell me whether these questions are out of physics...then I won't ask. Thank you
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
I just wanted to ask a genuine question which I had in my mind, namely the rotating box in an empty universe.
And that question has been answered. Did you not see the answers above? Especially my answer about “the shortest distance between two points is a straight line”.

Sushmit Nandy said:
it would be great if someone can tell me whether these questions are out of physics...then I won't ask
I don’t understand. Since we already answered, doesn’t that already indicate that we think they are in physics?
 
Dale said:
And that question has been answered. Did you not see the answers above? Especially my answer about “the shortest distance between two points is a straight line”.


I don’t understand. Since we already answered, doesn’t that already indicate that we think they are in physics?
Yes sir, I saw your answers and read them too. I was just asking that whether there is any non-fringe theory which is Machian. That was it. I didn't want to prolong any debate. After that box thought experiment, I just asked one question, that's it, which you had answered. But I just wanted to clear the fact, that I wasn't prolonging the debate. I just posted about Shape Dynamics by Julian Barbour, and then I didn't say anything. When, I got to know that I was being seen as argumentative, I just wanted to clear it. Thank you.
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
I was just asking that whether there is any non-fringe theory which is Machian
And I answered that too: Brans Dicke gravity.

It is just weird to ask a question, receive answers, and then suggest both that you haven’t received answers and that it is because we consider the question non-physical.


Sushmit Nandy said:
When, I got to know that I was being seen as argumentative
Nobody said you were being argumentative. Nor that you were prolonging the debate. The debate and argument continues in the broader scientific community.

I will provide some unasked advice to you: Concerns about Mach’s principle and other philosophical criteria (like Reichenbach’s) are not useful at this point in your studies. Learn the theory and the experimental evidence first. Once you have a solid understanding of that, then you can make an informed judgement if those principles are fulfilled in theory or in nature.
 
Dale said:
And I answered that too: Brans Dicke gravity.

It is just weird to ask a question, receive answers, and then suggest both that you haven’t received answers and that it is because we consider the question non-physical.



Nobody said you were being argumentative. Nor that you were prolonging the debate. The debate continues in the scientific community.

I will provide some unasked advice to you: Concerns about Mach’s principle and other philosophical criteria (like Reichenbach’s) are not useful at this point in your studies. Learn the theory and the experimental evidence first. Once you have a solid understanding of that, then you can make an informed judgement if those principles are fulfilled in theory or in nature.
Ok sir. I will follow it. And sir, I am sorry, if at any time I had been rude.