Other Your thoughts about "International Journal of Theoretical Physics"

Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around the legitimacy of the "International Journal of Theoretical Physics," following previous concerns about predatory journals. The user highlights that their paper was transferred from the "Journal of Foundations of Physics," which they consider valid, and notes that the journal is associated with Springer. They have successfully published one paper and received a recommendation for publication with minor revisions on a second paper. Despite these positive developments, the user expresses caution, recalling the adage that "if it seems too good to be true, it probably is." They seek advice on whether to proceed with publication in this journal or to consider more reputable options. The consensus indicates that while the journal is legitimate, it is not ranked among top-tier journals.
EternalStudent
Messages
51
Reaction score
3
A year ago, I asked a question about two journals, both of which were predatory ( https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/are-open-access-journals-legit-for-my-cv.990744/ ). Thanks to the overwhelming advice I have received, I did NOT publish in either of those journals.

Right now I am asking a question about a different journal, that I did not ask before. Namely, I am asking about "International Journal of Theoretical Physics". Two things that makes it seem legit is that

a) My paper was sent there by a transfer desk at "Journal of Foundations of Physics", and I assume that one to be valid
b) I believe it is part of Springer just like the "Foundations of Physics" one is

However, what happened is that I got the first paper published (the one transferred by the transferred desk), and now I have the second paper recommended for publication with "minor revisions" (and this second paper I submitted on my own without any transfer desk involved). Now, given my track record that it is very difficult for me to get anything published, I am starting to remember the saying "if it seems too good to be true it probably is". Can you take a look at that journal and let me know if it is worth it publishing there, or whether I should look for better journals?

Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
It's legit. It's also not a top journal.
 
Given the current funding situation, you should contact potential departments or research groups before you apply and pay any application fees. Many programs are not taking new graduate students at all this cycle because of funding uncertainty, unless a specific advisor can show they already have money to support you for five years. This is what I’ve heard directly from 20–30 programs. Do not waste money applying blindly.

Similar threads