How to get atoms of something having % of mass?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HCverma
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Atoms Mass
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a homework problem involving the calculation of the chemical formula for two oxides of a metal based on their percentage composition of oxygen. Participants explore methods to derive the formula of the second oxide from the given mass percentages of oxygen in both oxides, focusing on the relationships between atomic masses and the ratios of elements.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant states that the first oxide has one atom of oxygen, leading to the interpretation of the percentage as a direct representation of atomic mass.
  • Another participant suggests setting up equations based on atomic mass units (AMUs) without needing to compute them directly, proposing a ratio-based approach.
  • Several participants express confusion over the derivation of equations and seek clarification on the steps involved in manipulating the equations.
  • There is a discussion about the use of the distributive property in algebra to simplify equations related to mass ratios.
  • One participant mentions that the ratio of the masses is approximately 2.6232 and discusses how to use this ratio to solve for the number of metal atoms in the second oxide.
  • Another participant emphasizes the importance of understanding algebraic manipulation to solve the problem effectively.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on the best approach to solve the problem, with some advocating for ratio-based methods while others express confusion over the algebra involved. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the clarity of the mathematical steps and the interpretation of the results.

Contextual Notes

There are limitations in the discussion regarding the assumptions made about atomic masses and the need for clarity in the algebraic steps. Some participants struggle with the mathematical concepts, which affects their ability to follow the reasoning presented.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students studying chemistry and algebra, particularly those looking to improve their understanding of chemical formulas and mass percentage calculations.

HCverma
Messages
82
Reaction score
2

Homework Statement


Two oxides of a metal contain 27.6% and 30% of oxygen respectively. If the formula of the first oxide is MO, find that of the second?
Now my problem is how to find the atoms of O from the masses of 27.6% and 30.0 %?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution


I can see that in MO, there is one atom of O in the first oxide, So 27.6 = 1 oxygen atom?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
This is just deaing with ratios. You don;t even need to compute the AMU's.
Set up your equations. Om and Mm are your AMUs.

So you have:
Om = 0.276 (Om+Mm)
and you are looking for an integer solution for On and Mn to:
OnOm = 0.3 (OnOm+MnMm)

Take it from there.
 
.Scott said:
This is just deaing with ratios. You don;t even need to compute the AMU's.
Set up your equations. Om and Mm are your AMUs.
I don't understand the step above. Could you get it a little bit easier, please?
 
Let's see if I can be more helpful without spoiling the answer...

First, let me change my nomenclature to avoid confusion.
I will represent the AMUs as ##Mass_O## and ##Mass_M##

So you have: ##Mass_O = 0.276 (Mass_O+Mass_M)## thus ##0.724 Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M)##

Start by forgetting about the integer issue.
So we're looking for ##OM_X## where X is the number of metal atoms in the molecule - and we are going to let that be a non-integer for the time being.
So we have: ##Mass_O = 0.3(Mass_O+XMass_M)## thus ##0.7Mass_O = 0.3XMass_M##

Now for you:
* compute the ratio ##Mass_M/Mass_O## from the 1st equation above;
* use that ratio to compute X in the second equation;
* you should recognize X as being pretty close to a simple integer ratio;
* apply the numerator and denominator of that simple ratio to ##O_dM_n##

One more hint:
The numerator and denominator are each larger than 3.

Also:
If you need more assistance, show me how far you got in attempting to follow those four steps I just provided.
 
.Scott said:
Let's see if I can be more helpful without spoiling the answer...

First, let me change my nomenclature to avoid confusion.
I will represent the AMUs as ##Mass_O## and ##Mass_M##

So you have: ##Mass_O = 0.276 (Mass_O+Mass_M)## thus ##0.724 Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M)##

.
How do you get the above equeation? As I know Mass(O) = 0.276 and Mass(M) = 100 - 0.276 = 0.724.
Why have you written '##Mass_O = 0.276 (Mass_O+Mass_M)## thus ##0.724 Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M)##'? it should be only ##Mass_O = 0.276 and ##Mass_M = 0.724 Could you simplfy youe equation please?
 
We know that the mass of the Oxygen is 27.6% of the total mass. Thus:
##Mass_O = 0.276(Mass_O+Mass_M)##

Expanding that out:
##Mass_O = 0.276Mass_O+0.276Mass_M##

Subtracting ##0.276Mass_O## from each side of the equation:
##Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##

Thus:
##0.724Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
 
.Scott said:
We know that the mass of the Oxygen is 27.6% of the total mass. Thus:
##Mass_O = 0.276(Mass_O+Mass_M)##

Expanding that out:
##Mass_O = 0.276Mass_O+0.276Mass_M##

Subtracting ##0.276Mass_O## from each side of the equation:
##Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##

Thus:
##0.724Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
Could you clarify me here How you get '##0.724Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##' from '##Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##'?
 
HCverma said:
Could you clarify me here How you get '##0.724Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##' from '##Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##'?
It's the Distributive Property of Multiplication.

##Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
##1.0Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
##(1.0 - 0.276)Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
##(0.724)Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##

What is your grade level? You should have had this in High School Algebra class.
 
.Scott said:
It's the Distributive Property of Multiplication.

##Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
##1.0Mass_O - 0.276Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
##(1.0 - 0.276)Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##
##(0.724)Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M##

What is your grade level? You should have had this in High School Algebra class.
I passed high school but I am sorry to say, I am weak at math.
 
  • #10
HCverma said:
I passed high school but I am sorry to say, I am weak at math.
Then this is something you should rectify, sooner rather than later. As you should are seeing, your weakness in elementary algebra is preventing you from being proficient in parts of chemistry, particularly in balancing chemical reaction equations.

You should think about bolstering your math skills. One site that might be helpful is khanacademy.org. They have lots of videos in algebra, chemistry, and many more subjects.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: .Scott
  • #11
Mark44 said:
Then this is something you should rectify, sooner rather than later. As you should are seeing, your weakness in elementary algebra is preventing you from being proficient in parts of chemistry, particularly in balancing chemical reaction equations.

You should think about bolstering your math skills. One site that might be helpful is khanacademy.org. They have lots of videos in algebra, chemistry, and many more subjects.
Thanks a lot.
 
  • #12
.Scott said:
Let's see if I can be more helpful without spoiling the answer...

First, let me change my nomenclature to avoid confusion.
I will represent the AMUs as ##Mass_O## and ##Mass_M##

So you have: ##Mass_O = 0.276 (Mass_O+Mass_M)## thus ##0.724 Mass_O = 0.276Mass_M)##

Start by forgetting about the integer issue.
So we're looking for ##OM_X## where X is the number of metal atoms in the molecule - and we are going to let that be a non-integer for the time being.
So we have: ##Mass_O = 0.3(Mass_O+XMass_M)## thus ##0.7Mass_O = 0.3XMass_M##

Now for you:
* compute the ratio ##Mass_M/Mass_O## from the 1st equation above;
If you need more assistance, show me how far you got in attempting to follow those four steps I just provided.
the ratio is 181: 69
 
  • #13
Yes.
That is the first ratio. That's step 1.
2.6232

Now you should be able to use ##Mass_M/Mass_O = 2.6232## with the equation ##0.7Mass_O=0.3XMass_M## to solve for ##X##.
 
Last edited:
  • #14
.Scott said:
Yes.
That is the first ratio. That's step 1.
2.6232

Now you should be able to use ##Mass_M/Mass_O = 2.6232## with the equation ##0.7Mass_O=0.3XMass_M## to solve for ##X##.
Hw to solve X? X = 0.7 Masso / 0.3 Massm but here Massm / Masso = 2.6232. How to put the value in that equeation?
 
  • #15
HCverma said:
Hw to solve X? X = 0.7 Masso / 0.3 Massm but here Massm / Masso = 2.6232. How to put the value in that equation?
It will be a bit easier for us to work with ##Mass_O/Mass_M## than ##Mass_M/Mass_O##.
So let's start there: ##Mass_M/Mass_O = 2.6232##
Invert each side of that equation: ##Mass_O/Mass_M = 1/2.6232 = 0.38122##

Now back to this equation: ##0.7Mass_O = 0.3XMass_M##
What do we have to do to the left side of that equation to change it from ##0.7Mass_O## to ##Mass_O/Mass_M##?
Whatever you do to it, you have to do the same to the other side of that equation.
For example, if I added 99 to ##0.7Mass_O##, I would have to add 99 to ##0.3XMass_M## to keep both sides of the equation equal.
If I did that, I would have: ##0.7Mass_O + 99 = 0.3XMass_M + 99##. But that doesn't do us any good because we are looking to get ##Mass_O/Mass_M## on one side.

So what operation should we perform? Hint: It's not an addition or subtraction.

Also: I noticed that @Mark44 has made a suggestion in reply #10. Please take it to heart.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
3K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
11K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
4K