Solve Enjoyable Enigmas with Mr.E's Challenge

  • Thread starter Thread starter Enigman
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
Sign up Log in
1,043 replies · 208K views
Some additional solutions to the walk a mile south, west, north problem. If you find any circle around the souht pole which has circumference 1/n miles for n an integer, you can walk a mile north of that circle, then walk down to the circle, walk around the circle a bunch of times, then walk north again.

As a totally random aside, am I the only person who has a negative reaction to thinking about a blind guy reading a book, and his wife just turns the lights out on him? I realize there's no reason to leave the lights on if he's blind but there's still something very off-putting about it to me
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Office_Shredder said:
Some additional solutions to the walk a mile south, west, north problem. If you find any circle around the souht pole which has circumference 1/n miles for n an integer, you can walk a mile north of that circle, then walk down to the circle, walk around the circle a bunch of times, then walk north again.]
! Excellent point!
 
Office_Shredder said:
Some additional solutions to the walk a mile south, west, north problem. If you find any circle around the south pole which has circumference 1/n miles for n an integer, you can walk a mile north of that circle, then walk down to the circle, walk around the circle a bunch of times, then walk north again.

Yep, that was what I got too. Its an infinite set.
 
Darn it! I was working on this for the last hour, but Zooby beat me to the post. :cry:

Obviously, there is the North Pole. That's the only obvious answer. But near the South Pole, with the starting point just a little more than a mile away from the south pole, there exists an infinite number of latitudes that meet the requirement. But not just any latitude, it must meet some heavy restrictions. The starting distance from the South Pole, minus 1 mile, must be the radius of a circle who's circumference is exactly 1 mile divided by any natural number. In other words, that circle's circumference can be 1 mile, 1/2 mile, 1/3 mile, 1/4 mile, etc. Therefore the radius of the circle must be r = [1 mile]/(2πn), where n is a natural number (i.e. n = 1, 2, 3, 4, ...).

Going by the convention that latitudes are negative in the southern hemisphere, these latitudes will all be very near -90o Now we can calculate out these latitudes, L,

(π/180o)(90o + L)re - [1 mile] = [1 mile]/(2πn),

where re is the radius of the Earth, in units of miles.

A little algebra gives us

L = 90o(1 + 2πn)[1 mile]/(π2nre) - 90o
:smile:

[Edit: This answer does rely, in part, on the approximations that sinθ ≈ θ, cosθ ≈ 1, for very small θ (and θ is in units of radians). This is a fair approximation though, since 1 mile is much, much smaller than the circumference of the Earth.]
 
Last edited:
zoobyshoe said:
So, I want to state for the record, I found my answer legitimately before seeing your indiscretion.
Which one? Q&A, Braille or Earth?
zoobyshoe said:
I think additional clues should be the sole prerogative of the poster of the enigma, and should only be in response to explicit expressions of frustration by at least two respondents.
So, if I know the answer I can just blurt it out(in spoilers of course) and not give any clues?
Anywho Next one:
A science teacher told his after school class, "Whoever can get this egg into this smaller glass bottle will win no homework for a week! The rules are: the egg has to go into the bottle in one piece, and you can't break the bottle. You can also use anything in the science lab. So, do we have any volunteers?"

A boy raised his hand and the teacher pointed at him. The boy took the egg and looked around the science lab for the things he could use. He saw some writing paper, a pack of matches, some vinegar, a sink, and the glass bottle. By the end of the after school class, the boy had gotten the egg into the smaller bottle.
How did he do it?
[Note that, without doing anything to the egg, the egg can't fit into the bottle.
Also the trick works without vinegar, but I am just copy pasting it from a site after searching for this puzzle.]
 
Last edited:
collinsmark said:
Darn it! I was working on this for the last hour, but Zooby beat me to the post. :cry:
As Office Shredder pointed out, I missed an infinity of further answers and you didn't, so that makes your answer infinitely better than mine.
 
Enigman said:
Which one? Q&A, Braille or Earth?
South, west, north, same point.

So, if I know the answer I can just blurt it out(in spoilers of course) and not give any clues?
Why should you be giving open, unasked for clues to someone else's enigma? The point of spoilers is so people can avoid reading them if they want and work the solution themselves, despite the fact someone else may already have gotten the right answer. Lack of response doesn't mean everyone is stumped. People have other stuff to do, and may not even have read the riddle yet.
 
The spherical coordinate thing was barely a clue...And I was trying to get the attention to that Enigma...you people were stretching Braille too much...
Well, get the egg in the bottle now.
 
Egg and bottle-

I think it should be a hard boiled egg! That was very important.

Put the egg on the mouth of the bottle. Light the paper and use it to heat the neck of the bottle. This will raise the temperature of air inside the neck and create a localized low pressure region there. Since the outside pressure is same there will be a net downward external force acting on the egg, pushing it into the bottle. Vinegar can be used to decrease friction I guess. I heard this one many times.
 
Correct.
But
the egg doesn't need to be boiled, vinegar eats away the shell making it softer- but I have done it without either of these in 5th grade ...but it probably depends on the size of the mouth of bottle. Also burning paper should be inside the bottle to make it more efficient.
Next one:
Teacher wants the egg back out of the bottle, she needs the bottle for storing chemicals*. Without making a mess bring the egg out of bottle.
EDIT: Do it such that you don't affect the egg at all (except getting it out of the bottle). No boiling. *Not a hint.
 
Last edited:
The effect of vinegar is very cool. It dissolves the egg shell giving you a plump egg just held together by a membrane, like a water balloon. This gives me the following idea-
Just pour a very hypertonic solution into the bottle. All the water inside should leave the egg giving you a small egg surrounded by a big membrane. Then pour it all out of course.
 
Actually to do that you would need glacial acetic acid not just vinegar. Vinegar can only soften it so much in the short time of a few hours. To completely get rid of external shell you need 3-4 days, though it depends on concentration- I had to wait till a week to get my blood egg...(Hypertonic solution to take the moisture out and then red hypotonic solution). But it is a viable solution if time wasn't a constraint.
There is a simpler solution which doesn't involve any solutions...:biggrin:
Now I have got one strike after the next one (if there is one) I start giving hints.
 
Last edited:
consciousness said:
I heard this one many times.

I am quite sure, but what I wanted was an egg in a bottle; which you gave me...
Clichés are not my niche.
Mr.E
 
Cool the bottle or heat the surroundings. There should be many ways to do this...
 
mmm...nope...you don't have a fridge or anything to heat the surroundings with.
But you are on the right track, sort of. There is an easier and more efficient way of doing what you are trying to do...
 
You don't need anything except the bottle and egg. No equipments at all!
 
Sorry zoob et al. I am BORRRRRED...
to put the egg in the bottle you create a low pressure in the bottle. Now do the opposite. Take a deep breath and think...
 
Blow!
And out I bow.
 
The trick is to blow into the bottle when it is inverted. The burst of air bounces the egg before it reseals the bottle. This has two effects-
1)It as you say it increases the pressure inside the bottle.
2)(More important IMO) Creates low pressure at the mouth of the bottle by Bernoulli's equation.

An open ended question-

A black man, dressed in black, is crossing a road. He's blind and deaf. A truck is speeding towards him at great speed, with its lights turned off (probably a crazy driver). The starlight is very faint. The street lamps are also off and there's no moonlight. When the truck is about to hit the man, the driver hits the brakes and manages to stop just a few centimeters from him. How?
 
Er...
is Sunlight considered to be starlight?
 
Enigman said:
Er...
is Sunlight considered to be starlight?

Technically the sun is a star but not in the context of the puzzle.
 
Well, it was a day or there were lightning flashes or the driver had to pee or there was a helicopter overhead with search-lights or the pedestrian was wearing glow-in-the-dark (er...phosphorescent?) clothes or it was the ALIENS!
 
The answer-
Yes it was day.
 
Well, you did mention open-ended...
:biggrin:
 
You forgot night vision goggles :-p
 
Aliens trump all.
Alien-Guy.jpg
 
A physics enigma-

Two identical spheres receive identical amounts of thermal energy, the heat transfer occurring so quickly that none is lost to the surroundings. If they begin at the same temperature, but one is on a table and the other is suspended by a string, will the spheres still have the same temperature immediately after the quick addition of thermal energy?
 
Office_Shredder said:
Alternate solution: The man was standing at the edge of the parking spot the truck was driving to
That won't work...he was crossing a road.
 

Similar threads

High School Enjoyable Enigmas #2: Who Wins the Matchstick Game?
  • Enigman
  • · Replies 7 ·
  • General Math
Replies
7