Good Book Of Math Problems / On Problem Solving

AI Thread Summary
A user is seeking recommendations for books that present problems requiring creative problem-solving skills, as current textbooks primarily feature straightforward questions. They emphasize the need for practice to enhance their ability to tackle more challenging problems, particularly at a first-year college level in Calculus and Linear Algebra. Suggestions include Spivak's "Calculus" for its challenging problems and George Polya's "How to Solve It" for general problem-solving techniques. Additionally, online linear algebra notes are recommended for practice, along with the idea of proving theorems independently from textbooks to deepen understanding. The discussion also touches on the impact of a recent faculty strike on the user's study schedule, limiting their time for in-depth learning.
moe darklight
Messages
409
Reaction score
0
I'm looking for a good book with problems that require a creative approach, or on problem solving in general. Questions in my textbooks usually cover exactly what the chapter covered, and require little more than plugging numbers. There are maybe 2 or three problems in each chapter that require a little more thought, and sometimes I miss obvious answers; I feel this is because I don't get enough practice at approaching tougher problems. I figure the best way to hone this skill is practice.

I'm not looking for anything insanely tough here :biggrin: just a way to apply and connect what I'm learning in a different way. ... I'm first year first semester and have taken Calculus and Linear Algebra I, so it should be at that level.

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
as usual, the book by spivak, calculus, has many challenging problems. on general problem solving, the classic is "how to solve it" by the late great george polya of stanford. working through my online free linear algebra notes, the 15 page version, should serve as a good exercise for you, just filling in the gaps and doing the exercises, since you have already had the course of linear algebra.

here's a problem for you to start on: prove that if f is a differentiable function on an interval containing a<b, and if f'(a) < 0, and f'(b) > 0, then there is a point c between a and b where f'(c) =0. do NOT assume f' is continuous.

there are also contest books, e.g. from russia, with good problems. also in any book, trying to prove the theorems in that book without looking at the proofs given there is a superb exercise. I do it all the time in teaching nowdays, since otherwise if i read the stupid explanation in the lousy book we use i do not understand anything. but if i find a proof myself i understand it well and also can explain how i thought of it.
 
mathwonk said:
also in any book, trying to prove the theorems in that book without looking at the proofs given there is a superb exercise.

Yes, sometimes I try to do that. And while I'm reading the chapter I work out the examples and then continue reading to the explanation.
This semester has been a bit weird because the faculty went on a 3-week strike at my school, so we've been on sort of overdrive to catch up, so I haven't had as much time as I'd like to spend on any of the subjects.
 
This thread only works as a summary from the original source: List of STEM Masterworks in Physics, Mechanics, Electrodynamics... The original thread got very long and somewhat hard to read so I have compiled the recommendations from that thread in an online (Google Drive) spreadsheet. SUMMARY Permits are granted so you can make comments on the spreadsheet but I'll initially be the only one capable of edition. This is to avoid the possibility of someone deleting everything either by mistake...
By looking around, it seems like Dr. Hassani's books are great for studying "mathematical methods for the physicist/engineer." One is for the beginner physicist [Mathematical Methods: For Students of Physics and Related Fields] and the other is [Mathematical Physics: A Modern Introduction to Its Foundations] for the advanced undergraduate / grad student. I'm a sophomore undergrad and I have taken up the standard calculus sequence (~3sems) and ODEs. I want to self study ahead in mathematics...
Back
Top