Is Object Balancing Skill Real or Just an Illusion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter felix123
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the ability to balance objects on a single point, sparked by a video of a person demonstrating this skill. Participants express skepticism about the authenticity of such feats, suggesting that the performer might use tricks like glue or special surfaces. Theoretical principles of balance are acknowledged, particularly the importance of the center of gravity and the gravity vector. However, practical challenges, such as air disturbances, are noted as significant obstacles to achieving balance. Some contributors propose that using objects with small dimples or uneven surfaces could facilitate balance by providing multiple contact points, allowing for adjustments in the center of gravity. The conversation also touches on similar tricks, like balancing a salt shaker on its edge, emphasizing that these skills require practice and finesse. Ultimately, the consensus leans towards the idea that balancing is possible with the right techniques and support surfaces, rather than being a mere illusion.
felix123
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
I just watched this video of a guy who can balance any object on one point.

I tried it myself with some random objects and I grew so frustated that I thought this guy must be a fake! (maybe using glue or something)

Theoretically it seems possible, every object has a center of gravity and the line between the contact point and the center of gravity has to lie perfectly on the gravity vector.
But still in reality it seems unlikely as even the smallest disturbance (air etc..) would destroy the balance.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Maybe the trick is to balance stuff on a small object that has a dimple in it, so that the object does not rest on a single point but on, say, three points at least a few millimeters apart. Should be enough distance to be able to manually shift the center of gravity in between the points as seen from above.
 
Awesome vid. Thanks!
Just my opinion, I don't think it's fake.
 
if you notice he pays close attention to how he places the object before he tries to balance it. this is possible, but it would take a lot of practice. its not something you can do after a few hours of trying.
 
It reminds me of a parlour trick where you put some salt grains or sand grains in a very little pile on a smooth table top and then balance a salt shaker on its edge. A few grains will lodge themselves into the right position to jam the edge of the salt shaker. It takes practice but is impressive. If you get good, you need very little salt/sand so that no one notices it spread out on the table. Then when you are positioning the object you sweep the salt/sand into a little pile upon which you place the object.
 
Bowling ball juggling also impresses chicks.
 
Remember a seeing a guy in Sausilito on holiday how was/had balanced a tower of stones one on top of ech other. These where balanced on a point. Somehow they remained stable. I have apicture somehwere but I cannot find it.
 
If you notice he is always balancing on something, like a rock. It is the same principle as the salt and egg trick. The trick is that he isn't balancing on anything flat, hard and smooth. If it isn't flat, if it's rough like a rock, it's providing a very small amount of lateral support (the salt around the egg bottom) which is all that is necessary when something is balanced. No trick here, just the right rock or other support mechanism.
 

Similar threads

Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
182
Replies
30
Views
5K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Back
Top