Charges and forces problem

In summary, the problem involves four charges placed in a rectangle-like pattern, with three equal charges (A, B, D) and a fourth charge C. The question is what charge should C be in order for the net force at B to be zero. After visualizing the problem and using Coulomb's law, it is determined that C must affect A and D with forces equal in magnitude but opposite in direction to the resultant force (Fr) of A and D. This leads to a complicated equation that can only be simplified if the distances between the charges are equal. Therefore, the solution is only possible if d1 = d2.
  • #1
Rectifier
Gold Member
313
4
1. The problem
There are four charges hat are placed in a rectangle-like pattern. Three of them are equal (A, B, D).
What charge should C be so that the net force at charge B is zero?

2. Relevant information
WBuSAM6.png

(No distances are given)

3. The attempt
First of all, I did this image to visualize the problem.

h569of0.png


Charge A affects B with a force ## F_A ##. Charge D affects B with a force ## F_D ##. ## F_r ## is the resultant force of ## F_A ## and ## F_D ##.

I define the distance between ##AC=CA=DB=BD## to be equal to ##d_1##. The distance between ##CD=DC=AB=BA## is then equal to ##d_2##. Distance between ##BC=CB## can be derived from ##d_1## and ##d_2## with the help of the Pythagorean equation.
$$ d_3^2=d_1^2+d_2^2 $$

What we can see here is that the charge C must affect A with a force that has an equal magnitude but opposite direction to ## F_r ##. Hence
$$ F_{r} -F_{r}=0 $$

The force that affect these charges can be formulated with the help of Coulomb's law.
$$F=k \frac{Q_1 \cdot Q_2}{d^2} $$
This leads to following equations for the force that is affecting charge B$$F_D= k\frac{Q^2}{d_1^2}\\ F_A = k\frac{Q^2}{d_2^2} \\ F_{r}= k\frac{Q \cdot Q_c}{d_3^2}$$
The relationship between ##F_A##, ##F_D## and ##F_r## can be written with the help of the Pythagorean equation

$$ \\ F_{r}^2= F_D^2+F_A^2 $$

On this stage, I insert the equation for ##d_3^2## inside ##F_r## (force from C) and insert ##F_r, F_A## and ##F_D## into the equation for ##F_r## described by Pythagorean equation.

$$\\ F_{r}= k\frac{Q \cdot Q_c}{d_1^2+d_2^2} \\ (k\frac{Q \cdot Q_c}{d_1^2+d_2^2})^2 = (k\frac{Q^2}{d_1^2})^2+(k\frac{Q^2}{d_2^2} )^2 \\ $$

And here is where it gets crazy:

$$(k\frac{Q \cdot Q_c}{d_1^2+d_2^2})^2 = (k\frac{Q^2}{d_1^2})^2+(k\frac{Q^2}{d_2^2} )^2\\ (\frac{Q_c}{d_1^2+d_2^2})^2 = (\frac{Q}{d_1^2})^2+(\frac{Q}{d_2^2})^2 \\ Q_c^2 =( (\frac{Q}{d_1^2})^2+(\frac{Q}{d_2^2})^2 ) \cdot (d_1^2+d_2^2)^2 \\ Q_c^2 =Q^2 \frac{d_1^4+d_2^4}{(d_1d_2)^4} \cdot (d_1^2+d_2^2)^2$$

And here is the place that I am stuck on. I don't think it is possible to simplify it more.

Have I missed something?

Please help me. :,(
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Wow. Perhaps this is too difficult (read too much work) to tackle straight on.

When I look at the picture (good you made it!) I see that the only way to get F = 0 at B is if Fr is pointing straight at C. Because FC will be along the line BC.

So I would be inclined to say: now way, unless d1 = d2. Simplifies things a lot!

I sure hope this isn't a multiple choice question. Or am I completely off the rails with my limitation ?
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #3
BvU said:
Wow. Perhaps this is too difficult (read too much work) to tackle straight on.

When I look at the picture (good you made it!) I see that the only way to get F = 0 at B is if Fr is pointing straight at C. Because FC will be along the line BC.

So I would be inclined to say: now way, unless d1 = d2. Simplifies things a lot!

I sure hope this isn't a multiple choice question. Or am I completely off the rails with my limitation ?
Thank you for your comment!

This is an A-question from high school physics in Sweden. It isn't a multiple choice question, sadly, and I don't have a solution nor any clues to this problem.

Here is what I get if we assume that ##d_1=d_2## and it becomes a square (and that the last equation is correct).

$$Q_c^2 =Q^2 \frac{d_1^4+d_2^4}{(d_1d_2)^4} \cdot (d_1^2+d_2^2)^2 \\ Q_c^2 =Q^2 \frac{d^4+d^4}{(d^2)^4} \cdot (d^2+d^2)^2 \\ Q_c^2 =Q^2 \frac{2d^4}{d^8} \cdot 4d^4 \\ Q_c = \pm Q \sqrt{8} $$

Maybe I have missed something somewhere and that's what makes it so difficult. I have been sitting with this problem for some days now :,(
 
  • #4
Well, there is no sign ambiguity in this exercise ! A and D push, so C has to pull...

The √8 coefficient is correct: a factor √2 to compensate for the angle and a factor 2 to compensate for the distance.

I'm still looking for a way to prove that the thing can't be solved if ##d_1 \ne d_2##.



(I see a typo in my first reply: I really meant NO way, not now way).

Oh, and: you do everything using squares and Pythagoras. If you decompose FC along the lines BD and BA you get two components, of which both have to compensate for FD and FA, respectively. Doesn't help much (gets you a d1/d3 and d2/d3) but perhaps there I'll find our 'impossible!' proof...
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #5
Just playing around with this problem in my head, so I may have well made an algebra mistake. If you do as BvU suggests and compare components, I think you can get the following two equations:
\begin{eqnarray*}
Q_C &= Q\left(\frac{d_3}{d_1}\right)^3 \\
Q_C &= Q\left(\frac{d_3}{d_2}\right)^3.
\end{eqnarray*} These can only be satisfied simultaneously if ##d_1=d_2##, right?
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #6
BvU said:
Oh, and: you do everything using squares and Pythagoras. If you decompose FC along the lines BD and BA you get two components, of which both have to compensate for FD and FA, respectively. Doesn't help much (gets you a d1/d3 and d2/d3) but perhaps there I'll find our 'impossible!' proof...

Thank you both for the comments.

Here is the picture I have created to visualise your recuest.
fy1yeqo.png


I have tried a few things but can't get the same equations as vela:
\begin{eqnarray*}
Q_C &= Q\left(\frac{d_3}{d_1}\right)^3 \\
Q_C &= Q\left(\frac{d_3}{d_2}\right)^3.
\end{eqnarray*}

vela said:
These can only be satisfied simultaneously if ##d_1=d_2##, right?
I hope so! :D
 
  • #7
##|F_c| = k {Q_c Q\over d_3^2}\ ## Vertical component is ##F_c \, d_2/d_3##

##|F_a| = k {Q Q\over d_2^2}## So vertical sum = 0 ##\Leftrightarrow ##

## {Q_c Q\over d_3^2} {d_2\over d_3} + {Q Q\over d_2^2} = 0 \ \Leftrightarrow \ Q_c = - Q\left( {d_3\over d_2}\right)^3 ##
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #8
BvU said:
##F_c \, d_2/d_3##

Oh so you used similarity to get that!

I guess that we can say that this problem is solved. Or what do you think?

Thank you for help both of you.
 
  • #9
I used the cosine of the angle. And yes, the problem can't be solved unless d1 = d2.
 

1. What is the difference between a positive and negative charge?

A positive charge is caused by an excess of protons, while a negative charge is caused by an excess of electrons. Protons have a positive charge, while electrons have a negative charge. Opposite charges attract each other, while like charges repel each other.

2. How does the distance between two charges affect the strength of the force between them?

The force between two charges is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. This means that as the distance between charges increases, the force decreases. Conversely, as the distance decreases, the force increases.

3. What is Coulomb's law and how is it used to calculate the force between two charges?

Coulomb's law states that the force between two charges is directly proportional to the product of the charges and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. It can be used to calculate the force between two charges by using the formula F = k(q1q2)/r^2, where F is the force, k is the Coulomb's constant, q1 and q2 are the charges, and r is the distance between them.

4. Can two objects with the same charge attract each other?

No, two objects with the same charge will repel each other. This is because like charges repel each other, as stated by the law of electrostatics. Only objects with opposite charges will attract each other.

5. How do electric fields relate to charges and forces?

An electric field is a region in space where an electric charge experiences a force. The strength and direction of the electric field are determined by the charges present in that region. The electric field is directly related to the force between two charges, as the force is the product of the electric field and the charge of the object experiencing the force.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
2
Replies
42
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
11
Views
168
  • Set Theory, Logic, Probability, Statistics
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
3
Views
452
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
23
Views
286
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
806
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top