A question about the trajectory of movement

  • Thread starter Ivan Nikiforov
  • Start date
11 replies · 3K views · last reply
Ivan Nikiforov
Messages
173
Reaction score
36
Good afternoon! I would like to ask for your help with the following question. Am I correct in understanding that the rotation of a circle regarding point A and the rotation of point A regarding the circle have different relative trajectories?


Diagram of two overlapping circles: a blue circle with four small circles marked on its rim, one labelled A at the top, joined by double-headed arrows across its centre, and an orange dashed circle offset upward and to the right.

Diagram of a solid blue circle with a dashed orange circle of equal size offset upward and to the left, overlapping it. Point A is marked at the top of the blue circle and at the right end of a horizontal dashed radius, with a vertical double-headed arrow between the top and bottom of the blue circle.

Diagram of two solid blue circles of equal size, offset diagonally, with a dash-dot orange circle in between passing through point A, which is marked on the upper right of the middle circle. Small circles mark points on the blue circles, with vertical double-headed arrows linking them and a dashed horizontal line from the centre to A.
 
I feel there is not enough information in your diagrams.

Which circle?
What motion?
How are the 3 diagrams related?
What do the arrows indicate?
What do the dotted lines indicate?
 
Two points are conventionally highlighted on the blue circle. They are represented by small circles. The arrows indicate the direction from the center of the circle to the selected points. There is a point A next to the circle. Option #1: Point A is stationary. The circle is rotating. When it is rotated clockwise, the selected points rotate simultaneously. The upper point is to the right of point A, and the lower point is to the left of point A (Fig. 1). Option number 2. The circle is stationary. Point A rotates relative to the center of the circle. When it is rotated clockwise, the selected points of the circle appear to the left of the new position of point A (Figure 2). An observer at point A will see such a movement as the center of the circle moves along the trajectory of the orange line (Figure 3). Is this understanding of the process correct?
 
Last edited:
This description is written with a chatbot. It describes one of the diagrams, but there are four diagrams.

Is there some reason why you can't label the diagrams themselves?
 
DaveC426913 said:
This description is written with a chatbot.
That is not good. Thread is closed temporarily for Moderation.
 
  • Sad
Likes   Reactions: Ivan Nikiforov
After a DM discussion with the OP, he assures me he did not use a chatbot for his posts in this thread. So the thread is reopened provisionally. Thanks for your patience.
 
In have tried to re-diagram this for clarity.

Ivan Nikiforov said:
Two points are conventionally highlighted on the blue circle. They are represented by small circles. The arrows indicate the direction from the center of the circle to the selected points. There is a point A next to the circle.
I have shrunk the circle-points to points.
I have added a label B to the second point and labeled the centre of the circle 'O'.
I have removed the arrows and antipodal points, as well as the orange circle until they are mentioned.
So far, what you have described is this:
Diagram of a blue circle with centre O and two labelled black points on its circumference, A at the top and B to the upper right of A.


Ivan Nikiforov said:
Option #1: Point A is stationary. The circle is rotating. When it is rotated clockwise, the selected points rotate simultaneously. The upper point is to the right of point A, and the lower point is to the left of point A (Fig. 1).
Diagram of two circles with points marked: a blue circle with centre O' and point A on its edge, and a faint grey circle with centre O and point B on its edge; point B' lies on the blue circle, with curved orange arrows showing movement from O to O' and from B to B'.

OK, so B transforms from to the right of A to in front of A (from A's point of view, looking toward the bottom of the diagram).

Yes, all other points on the circle will likewise rotate clockwise about point A:
Diagram of two circles with points A, B, O and O' labelled, with curved orange arrows showing point movement; one circle is blue and solid, the other is faint grey.


Ivan Nikiforov said:
Option number 2. The circle is stationary. Point A rotates relative to the center of the circle. When it is rotated clockwise, the selected points of the circle appear to the left of the new position of point A (Figure

Blue circle with centre O and two marked points A (right side) and B (lower right), with orange curved arrows showing clockwise motion around the circle.

No, they will move clockwise. That is not always left in all cases.

Ivan Nikiforov said:
2). An observer at point A will see such a movement as the center of the circle moves along the trajectory of the orange line (Figure 3).
The circle is stationary; you said so, above. It cannot move along any trajectory.

Ivan Nikiforov said:
Is this understanding of the process correct?
I don't know. Do these modified diagrams help clear it up?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Agree
Likes   Reactions: berkeman and phinds
Good afternoon! Thank you for your comment! I will try to explain the question in more detail. Points B and C are highlighted on the blue circle. Point A is located next to the circle (Fig. 1).

Diagram of a blue circle with center O, a point B on its top edge, a point C on its bottom edge, and a separate point A above and outside the circle.

If the circle rotates clockwise, then points B and C rotate simultaneously relative to point O. As a result, point B is to the right of point A, and point C is to the left of point A (Figure 2).
Diagram of a blue circle with center O, a point A above the circle, and points B and C on the circle's right and left sides, all labeled.

If point A rotates counterclockwise, it moves to a new position where point B is to the right and point C is to the left (Figure 3).
Diagram of a blue circle with center O, labeled points B at the top and C at the bottom on the circumference, and point A outside the circle to the left.

Thus, from the perspective of the final positions of points A, B, and C, these two types of movement are the same. However, when point A rotates, points B and C do not rotate relative to point O. This is equivalent to moving the circle with points B, O, and C to a position to the right of the original position of point A. That is, we can say that for an observer at point A, the circle with points B, O, and C moves along an orange trajectory in a counterclockwise direction (Figure 4). Is this reasoning correct?
Diagram of a blue circle centred at O with points B and C on it, a point A outside the circle, and a dash-dot orange circle of the same size through A, plus a dashed black circle and a straight arrow from its centre to O.
 
Attachments
  • Geometric construction: a blue circle with centre O and marked points B (top) and C (bottom), a point A to its left, a solid line from the lower-left to O, an orange circle around A, and a dashed black circle below-left.
    1750705861184.webp
    8.7 KB · Views: 66
  • Diagram of a blue circle centred at O with points B and C on its top and bottom, a point A to its right, an orange circle of equal size passing through O, and a dashed black circle below, with a line from O to a point on the dashed circle.
    1750704848825.webp
    11.6 KB · Views: 90
  • Diagram of a blue circle with centre O, marked points B on the top of the circle and C at the bottom, and a separate point A above and to the left of B, outside the circle.
    1750704369905.webp
    6.7 KB · Views: 67
  • Circle centred at O with three marked points on its edge: A and B close together near the top, and C at the bottom.
    1750704228953.webp
    5.2 KB · Views: 60
Last edited:
Ivan Nikiforov said:
Hello! Thank you for your comment! I will try to explain the question in more detail. On the blue circle, points B and C are highlighted. Next to the circle is point A (Fig. 1).

View attachment 362461
If the circle rotates clockwise, then points B and C rotate simultaneously relative to point O. As a result, point B ends up to the right of point A, and point C ends up to the left of point A (Fig. 2).
View attachment 362462
Point B ends up "to the right" of A from our overhead vantage point.

It is important we are clear whose "right" we are talking about, in any given scenario.

Ivan Nikiforov said:
If point A rotates counterclockwise, it moves to a new position in which point B is on the right and point C is on the left (Fig. 3).

View attachment 362465
Hang on. "If A rotates counterclockwise" is ambiguous. An object rotating usually means "about its own centre point". What you mean is "If A is rotated about point O".

Ivan Nikiforov said:
Thus, from the perspective of the final positions of points A, B, and C, these two types of movement are the same.
Great so far.

Ivan Nikiforov said:
However, when point A rotates, points B and C do not rotate relative to point O. This is equivalent to moving the circle with points B, O, and C to a position to the right of the original position of point A.

"to the right of A" from whose perspective? Again, I think you mean "from our overhead vantage point".

And be careful with words such as "equivalent".

See below:


Ivan Nikiforov said:
That is, we can say that for an observer at point A, the circle with points B, O, and C moves along an orange trajectory in a counterclockwise direction (Figure 4). Is this reasoning correct?
View attachment 362466
Well, an observer has an orientation. They are facing a certain way.


In the first scenario you start like this:
Small diagram with a letter A beside a blue dot marking a point, with a small arrow or curved mark near it.
and end like this:
Small diagram showing a point labelled A with a small blue dot beside it.
.

But in the second scenario, you start like this:
Small diagram showing a label A with a small blue dot beside it, likely marking a point on a rotating figure.
but end like this:
Small black arrow pointing up and left with a blue dot below and to the right, marking the position of point B.




So, is it really "equivalent" for the observer at point A? That's up to you if you want to ignore their orientation - the induced rotation about their own center point.

I'd say you've got the geometry itself right, it's a question of being explicit in your descriptions of what's going on: do points have "orientation", or "directions of observation"? I would say a point does not, by default. But adding "observers" at the locations changes things.

It'll be fine as long as you are careful consistent in your descriptions. And - when you are breaking from an established consistency - explicitly state it.
 
Last edited:
Thank you! Indeed, the points do not have an orientation or direction of observation. Only their final position and trajectory matter. In fact, this question is related to the observation of the electric and magnetic fields at points B and C, as well as at point A. The figure below shows the addition of magnetic induction vectors directed from point O to the circle. For convenience, only two opposite vectors are shown. As a result, when the circle rotates clockwise, points B and C move in opposite directions. As a result, the surface of the circle facing us becomes positively charged.
Diagram of a circle with centre O, a point A above it outside the circle, and a diameter drawn through O with endpoints labelled B and C, each with a short arrow along the line.


If point A rotates, the circle moves equivalently to the right and up without rotation. For point A, the upper half of the circle's surface is positively charged, while the lower half is negatively charged. As a result, the observer at point A sees a zero charge on the circle's surface. I believe this explains why my generator is not working. Thank you again!
Geometric diagram of a blue circle with points B and C at its top and bottom, a dashed black circle and an orange dash-dot circle, point A inside the blue circle, and a vector arrow from a centre point to the blue circle's centre.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a blue circle with a point A above it and a diameter line with arrows labelled B1 at both ends, with a dot at the centre.
    1750708854380.webp
    5.3 KB · Views: 79
Cool. I think this has advanced from a generic geometry problem to a problem with a specific application.

I've reported the thread to see if the moderators agree that you might get better answer in a forum watched by those knowledgeable in electrical and magnetic induction principles.
 
Thank you! I think that thanks to you, I found the answer to my question. The problem was in the field of geometry. When developing the design of the generator, I considered this process, but I made a wrong conclusion. I thought that if the final positions of the points were the same, then the trajectories and observed fields would also be the same. However, this turned out to be incorrect.