Abstract prime factorization proof

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
7 replies · 3K views
kathrynag
Messages
595
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A positive integer a is called a square if a=n^2 for some n in Z. Show that the integer a>1 is a square iff every exponent in its prime factorization is even.



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


Well, I know a=p1^a1p2^a2...pn^a^n is the definition of prime factorization.
We let p=2n because any even number squared is an even numbers.
Not sure how to continue.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I keep trying to work on this one on I'm getting nowhere. Am I on the right track or does anyone have a suggestion?
 
It's not an even number; the exponents are even.

So in the prime factorization of a, [itex]{a_1,a_2,...,a_n}[/itex] are even. Now what does that mean about the square root of a?
 
@kathrynag,

When you have an "iff" problem, you really have to solve two problems. Here's a restatement of the problem to make this more clear:
Let a > 1 be an integer.

1. Assume that a is a square. Prove that every exponent in its prime factorization is even.

2. Assume that every exponent in a's prime factorization is even. Prove that a is a square.

Does this help?
 
Petek said:
@kathrynag,

When you have an "iff" problem, you really have to solve two problems. Here's a restatement of the problem to make this more clear:
Let a > 1 be an integer.

1. Assume that a is a square. Prove that every exponent in its prime factorization is even.

2. Assume that every exponent in a's prime factorization is even. Prove that a is a square.

Does this help?
Yeah, that does help. I fell better about the 2nd part of the proof.
The first part still worries me.
Assume n is a square. Then we have a=n^2
That's about as far as I get with that one.
I know what I need to prove, but it's getting there.
n^2=p1^a1p2^a2...pn^an
 
hgfalling said:
It's not an even number; the exponents are even.

So in the prime factorization of a, [itex]{a_1,a_2,...,a_n}[/itex] are even. Now what does that mean about the square root of a?

It is also even.
 
No. Consider 9. Its prime factorization is [itex]3^2[/itex]. Therefore it satisfies the rules of your problem. But it's not even, nor is it the square of an even number.
 
kathrynag said:
Yeah, that does help. I fell better about the 2nd part of the proof.
The first part still worries me.
Assume n is a square. Then we have a=n^2
That's about as far as I get with that one.
I know what I need to prove, but it's getting there.
n^2=p1^a1p2^a2...pn^an

Hint: Write out the prime factorization for n and then use that to come up with another prime factorization for n^2.