Acidic strength of phenol with isotopic oxygen i.e O 18 and just phenol

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sat-P
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Phenol
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the comparison of acidic strength between phenol and phenol with isotopic oxygen (O-18). The main point of confusion involves the stability of the conjugate base and the implications of zero point energy (ZPE) in this context. O-18, while having the same number of protons as O-16, possesses two additional neutrons, affecting its mass and vibrational characteristics. The isotope effect is highlighted, indicating that the ZPE of an oscillator decreases with increased mass, leading to different vibrational energies for O-18 and O-16. This difference influences the activation energy required for dissociation pathways, complicating predictions about acidic strength. The discussion emphasizes that the effects of O-18/O-16 isotopes are generally smaller compared to hydrogen/deuterium isotope effects, making the analysis of acidic strength more intricate.
Sat-P
Messages
53
Reaction score
4
I have a doubt between the acidic strength of phenol with isotopic oxygen i.e O 18 and just phenol
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
What kind of doubt do you have?
 
Acidic strength comparison between phenol and phenol with O18
 
I don't know how to compare between
 
O18 has 2 extra proton so conjugate base must be more stable than that in O??
 
O18 has the same number of protons as O16.
 
It has two extra neutrons
 
I searched it somewhere and they said something about zero point energy. But I dont understand what it is!!
 
Sat-P said:
I searched it somewhere and they said something about zero point energy. But I dont understand what it is!!
It’s an example of the isotope effect. This is a really complex topic, but a simplified explanation goes like this: the zero point energy of an oscillator decreases with increasing mass, so the O-18 phenol OH vibration will have a lower ZPE than O-16 H. In addition, the transition state ZPE to break the OH bond will be different. In general these two ZPEs don’t decrease by the same amount, so one dissociation pathway will have a lower activation energy than the other. Predicting the magnitude and sign of this difference can be very complicated, but the magnitude is generally proportional to the mass difference between the isotopes. So O-18/O-16 isotope effects will be quite a bit smaller than H/D isotope effects. This page has a pretty good explanation with pictures and examples:
https://chem.libretexts.org/Bookshe...l_Harmonic_Oscillator/Kinetic_Isotope_Effects
 
Back
Top