Advice about Dremel cutting wheels

  • #1
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Summary:
Is there a better option than ceramic cut off wheels for going through brass hobby tubing?
As mentioned in another post, I'm cutting brass hobby tubing. I'm cutting a lot of brass hobby tubing. Like several hundred cuts. I'm using a Dremel, but I'm open-minded.

Using the little ceramic cutting wheels is cheap, and easily replaced when they break, but they are slow and they waste a lot of brass.
I'm cutting rings of brass barely a millimeter or two long, and the cutting wheels eats up a mm or so of material, so if I cut 100 cross sections each 2mm long, I have to cut away 1 mm of material. Not that I care about the cost, it's more about the speed.

Does anyone have suggestions about a better way to cut brass hobby tubing?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Baluncore
Science Advisor
8,964
3,548
Does anyone have suggestions about a better way to cut brass hobby tubing?
Mount a close fitting internal mandrel in the chuck of a lathe. Slide a short stock brass tube onto the mandrel. Mount a tube cutter wheel on the toolpost. Cut brass tube against the mandrel, slide tube along by hand, repeat until mandrel is full, then unload and continue.
 
  • #3
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Mount a close fitting internal mandrel in the chuck of a lathe. Slide a short stock brass tube onto the mandrel. Mount a tube cutter wheel on the toolpost. Cut brass tube against the mandrel, slide tube along by hand, repeat until mandrel is full, then unload and continue.
Took me six reads to understand first what you were describing and second why it was a better method. :wink:

But the key is the tube cutter wheel. Interesting.

So, one of the things that works to my advantage is that I have 19 sizes of tube - all the which nest with just a few micrometer's gap - from 5/8" down to 1/16", and I can cut them while nested. I get 19 rings for one cut. And it also ensures that I don't distort the tubes when cutting.

I wonder if I can adapt my idea to use a tube cutting wheel, as you suggest. The nested tubes will take the place of your mandrel...
 
  • #4
Baluncore
Science Advisor
8,964
3,548
I wonder if I can adapt my idea to use a tube cutting wheel, as you suggest. The nested tubes will take the place of your mandrel...
I use it with one tube, but I don't expect it will work with more than two. In effect the tube is free to be pinched between the mandrel and the tube cutter wheel. There needs to be a hard inner support to cut against, and the intermediate tubes need to be driven to rotate against the cutter.

The tube cutter wheel profile will be critical if nested tubes are to be cut to the same length. Maybe consider an asymmetric cutter wheel, flat on one side, so the outer cut-off ends can move away from the cutter as the depth of cut increases?

To cut nested tube in a lathe chuck, I would consider a powered thin cutting disk or saw mounted on a tool post, like a tool post grinder.
 
  • #5
berkeman
Mentor
59,420
9,539
Summary:: Is there a better option than ceramic cut off wheels for going through brass hobby tubing?

Does anyone have suggestions about a better way to cut brass hobby tubing?
Sorry if I'm missing the obvious, but why not use a standard plumbing tube cutter?

[Legal disclaimer: I have not read Dave's other thread, so I may be negligent in my duties here. Also, I do not stay up late at night like some other users here <cough>, so I may have missed some other conversations about this. Nolo contendere...]

1615765552125.png

https://www.dhresource.com/0x0/f2/a...-tube-cutter-cutting-tool-18cm-adjustable.jpg
 
  • #6
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Sorry if I'm missing the obvious, but why not use a standard plumbing tube cutter?
Yeah, now I remember why.

I'm cutting tubing lengths on the order of 2 mm. Like the pic. Tube cutters can't do that.

1615766799541.png
 
  • #7
Baluncore
Science Advisor
8,964
3,548
Also, I do not stay up late at night like some other users here <cough>, ...
It is 11 AM here, and the Sun has been up since 7 AM. I think you sleep in for too long.

The reason for using the cutting wheel from a tube cutter against an internal mandrel is that the thin tube needs some support to stop it flexing. There is no need for the lathe if the mandrel is a close fit, and the pipe cutter can be kept square with the tube, so it does not cut a helical line.

I cut it in a lathe because I can repeat the cut against a fixed gauge and cut it square, even when the tube is flexible brass of softer plastic.
 
  • #8
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
The reason for using the cutting wheel from a tube cutter against an internal mandrel is that the thin tube needs some support to stop it flexing. There is no need for the lathe if the mandrel is a close fit, and the pipe cutter can be kept square with the tube, so it does not cut a helical line.

I cut it in a lathe because I can repeat the cut against a fixed gauge and cut it square, even when the tube is flexible brass of softer plastic.
Right. So it will work whereas a standard tube cutter won't because a standard tube cutter needs a brace in either side the wheel. A lathe does not.

Now all I need is a lathe...
 
  • #10
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Is your birthday coming up? :wink:
As a matter of fact... it's coming up in exactly 364 days. No guff.
 
  • #11
berkeman
Mentor
59,420
9,539
As a matter of fact... it's coming up in exactly 364 days. No guff.
Happy Belated Birthday! Just sayin'...
 
  • #12
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Thanks!

I plan to trade myself in for three nineteen-year-olds: one to sleep, one to work and one to play.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Likes phinds and berkeman
  • #13
Lnewqban
Gold Member
1,233
701
If you don't have a lathe, you may be able to achieve the next best by replacing the lathe with a press drill or even the locked-in-position Dremel, doing the cut with a sharp steel knife against a rotating mandrel, previously turned out of aluminum or even hard wood.

For the smaller diameters, you could try this technique, perhaps improving it somehow to increase the precision of the cut:


 
Last edited:
  • #14
jrmichler
Mentor
1,458
1,638
Would this work? Slitting saw: https://www.mcmaster.com/slitting-saws. Scroll down to the smooth finish saws.

Possibly mount the saw on an arbor, chuck the arbor in a drill press, then make a fixture to hold the tubing vertically and move the tubing past the saw similar to a table saw tipped 90 degrees.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes DaveC426913, Lnewqban and berkeman
  • #15
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
If you don't have a lathe, you may be able to achieve the next best by replacing the lathe with a press drill
Is that anything like a drill press? :wink: I have one of those.

or even the locked-in-position Dremel, doing the cut
Yeah. When I was experimenting, I built a jig to hold the Dremel in-place and a tray to slide the tubing into it.

with a sharp steel knife
By this, do you mean a knife made of steel like an Exacto blade, or do you mean something else?

against a rotating mandrel, previously turned out of aluminum or even hard wood.
If I play my cards right, the thinner tubes will act as support for the thicker ones. For all intents and purposes I am cutting slices of a 5/8" solid brass bar.


For the smaller diameters, you could try this technique, perhaps improving it somehow to increase the precision of the cut:
I'm going to stick to tubes of at least 3/16" diameter. Anything thinner will just fold on me when my device is manipulated.
 
  • #16
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Would this work? Slitting saw: https://www.mcmaster.com/slitting-saws. Scroll down to the smooth finish saws.

Possibly mount the saw on an arbor, chuck the arbor in a drill press, then make a fixture to hold the tubing vertically and move the tubing past the saw similar to a table saw tipped 90 degrees.
Cool. Checking that out. Thanks.

I'm not sure how I'd attach this to a drill press or Dremel. Those ... er... "arbor holes"? are huge - like, a 1/2" to 1".

(OK, it looks like there is some sort of arbor chuck that facilitates this.)
 
Last edited:
  • #17
Lnewqban
Gold Member
1,233
701
Is that anything like a drill press? :wink: I have one of those.

By this, do you mean a knife made of steel like an Exacto blade, or do you mean something else?
Sorry, I meant a press drill.
I like @Baluncore idea best, mine is just a less precise way to do it because you don't have a micro lathe.

An Exacto blade could work, or any other sharp knife, provide that you wear eye and hand protection while experimenting with that idea.

 
  • #21
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
how about these copper ring shims?

https://www.mcmaster.com/washers/ring-shims-6/
Sorry, the rings are part of a larger structure that is also composed of brass tubing and must be of exact size, down to a dozen micrometers.





2610456927_1194873890455683072_o__32625.1566227200.jpg


The cylinders are about 1" long each, and the rings are stoppers.

Here's six nested cylinders (long, grey), each with 3 stopper rings (short grey) soldered or glued to them (blue.)


1615815281117.png

This unit will telescope from about 1.25" to about 6".
I need 24 of them. Each of which requires 18 rings.
 
Last edited:
  • #22
224
150
Maybe I'm missing some subtle issue, but with the right mandrels, which everyone else is mentioning anyway, wouldn't you be able to use a standard tube cutter? Just slide a scrap piece down the mandrel to rest against the piece you want to cut, and it will be supported on both sides. You would need a mandrel for each size of tube you want to cut, but it should work.
 
  • #23
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
Maybe I'm missing some subtle issue, but with the right mandrels, which everyone else is mentioning anyway, wouldn't you be able to use a standard tube cutter? Just slide a scrap piece down the mandrel to rest against the piece you want to cut, and it will be supported on both sides. You would need a mandrel for each size of tube you want to cut, but it should work.
That's very true.
 
  • #24
275
211
That looks like it's gonna be a lot of fun to assemble.
 
  • Like
Likes DaveC426913
  • #25
DaveC426913
Gold Member
19,327
2,800
That looks like it's gonna be a lot of fun to assemble.
Early prototype, soldered.

1615841984666.png


The key metric is that it must allow the object's sides to expand by at least a factor of 2 root(2) - i.e. ~1:2.828.

Not too hard, except that this cylinder only a part of the object's sides. The joint/corner elements take up room but do not likewise telescope - which means the cylinders must do a fair bit better than 1:2.828. Which is why I need to add nesting cylinders to the design until I achieve a sufficient telescoping ratio.
 
  • Like
Likes MRFMengineer, Tom.G, Baluncore and 1 other person

Related Threads on Advice about Dremel cutting wheels

  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
729
Replies
8
Views
14K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
35
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
995
Top