Angle for a projectile that must clear 2 walls

6 replies · 3K views · last reply
ThomasMagnus
Messages
138
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A cannon is aimed at a target located 72m away from the cannon and 20m above the ground. The cannon ball, when fired, will have the initial speed of 32m/s, but it has to clear a 13m wall between the cannon and the target as, shown. At what angle should the cannon be fired?

**Diagram attached

Homework Equations


Dy=(Voy)(t)+(1/2)(a)(t)2

Vx=Dx/t

The Attempt at a Solution


I have tried to do this question many different ways, but I have not been able to find the correct answer.

Here is what I have tried:
For the first wall Dx= 15, Dy=13, Vx=32cos([tex]\theta[/tex]) Voy=32sin([tex]\theta[/tex])
and since Vx=Dx/t ,Dx/Vx=t then t=15/32cos([tex]\theta[/tex])
Dy=Vot+1/2(a)(t)2

13=(32sin([tex]\theta[/tex])(15/32cos([tex]\theta[/tex])+(1/2)(-9.8)(15/32cos(theta)2


I am going to stop here for help because I don't think I am doing this correctly.

Thank you! =)
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a cannon on the left firing at 32 m/s at an angle, with a 13 m wall 15 m away and a target 57 m beyond the wall, 20 m above the ground.
    Untitled.png
    12.7 KB · Views: 542
Try to hit the target first. You will likely get two values of θ that will allow the projectile to hit the target. See if either or both or neither will allow the projectile to clear the wall.

Therefore, use Dx = 72 m and Dy = 20 m
 
Should I use this equation: Dy=(Voy)(t)+(1/2)(a)(t)^2 and substitute 72/32cos(theta) in for t?

thanks
 
ThomasMagnus said:
Should I use this equation: Dy=(Voy)(t)+(1/2)(a)(t)^2 and substitute 72/[32cos(theta)] in for t?

thanks

Yes. Also, Dy = 20 , V0y = 32 sin(θ) .
 
I'm having some problems with the algebra in the equations; I haven't done much work with trig identities.

Here's my attempt at solving the equaiton:

Dy=20, Dx=72, Voy=32[sin[tex]\theta[/tex]], and like we established: t=72/32[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]
Dy=Voyt + 1/2(a)(t)2

20= 32[sin[tex]\theta[/tex]] (72/32[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]) + 1/2(-9.8){(72/32[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]}2

Here is where I get mixed up:

{72/32[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]}2

Would this be equal to 722/322[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]
or 722/322cos2[tex]\theta[/tex]
or 722/322 [cos(theta)]2

or even 722/32[cos(theta)]2?
 
I was searching on the internet for help on this question, and I came across a formula that was from wikipedia's "Trajectory of a projectile page"

It says you can use the following formula to find the Angle θ required to hit coordinate (x,y)

Equation: theta = arctan of (v squared plus or minus the square root of (v to the fourth minus g times (gx squared plus 2yv squared)), all divided by gx).


and it worked!
I got 63 degrees and 42 degrees, just like to book says. Thank God my instructor said that we can copy any formulas that are useful onto the formula sheet!

What do you think of this? Is there any easier ways to do this?

Thanks!
 
ThomasMagnus said:
I'm having some problems with the algebra in the equations; I haven't done much work with trig identities.

Here's my attempt at solving the equation:

Dy=20, Dx=72, Voy=32[sin[tex]\theta[/tex]], and like we established: t=72/32[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]] When you write it this way, cos(θ) is not in the denominator, but it should be.
Write: t=72/[32cos(θ)]

Dy=Voyt + 1/2(a)(t)2

20= 32[sin[tex]\theta[/tex]] (72/[32cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]) + 1/2(-9.8){(72/[32cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]}2

Here is where I get mixed up:

{72/32[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]]}2

Would this be equal to 722/322[cos[tex]\theta[/tex]] No
or 722/322cos2[tex]\theta[/tex] Yes, for the expression you asked about.
or 722/322 [cos(theta)]2 Yes, for the expression you asked about.

or even 722/32[cos(theta)]2? No


ThomasMagnus said:
I was searching on the internet for help on this question, and I came across a formula that was from Wikipedia's "Trajectory of a projectile page"

It says you can use the following formula to find the Angle θ required to hit coordinate (x,y)

Formula: theta equals arctan of the quantity (v squared plus or minus the square root of v to the fourth minus g times (g x squared plus 2 y v squared), all divided by g x).


and it worked!
I got 63 degrees and 42 degrees, just like to book says. Thank God my instructor said that we can copy any formulas that are useful onto the formula sheet!

What do you think of this? Is there any easier ways to do this?

Thanks!
Yes, the algebra is quite messy. The Wikipedia article you mentioned does show how the formula is obtained. IMO, knowing where it comes from is much more important than using some formula you don't understand.

20 = 32[sinθ] (72/[32cosθ]) + 1/2(-9.8){(72/[32cosθ]}2

→ 0 = 1/2(9.8){(72/[32cosθ]}2 - 32[sinθ] (72/[32cosθ]) + 20

→ 0 = (4.9)722sec2θ/322 - 72tanθ + 20

→ 0 = (4.9)722(1+tan2θ)/322 - 72tanθ + 20

→ 0 = (4.9)722tan2θ/322 - 72tanθ + 20 + (4.9)722/322

Use the quadratic formula to solve for tanθ .