Are Newton’s laws of motion an arbitary choice?

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter Sushmit Nandy
  • Start date
7 replies · 672 views · last reply
Sushmit Nandy
Messages
18
Reaction score
4
Are Newton’s laws an arbitary choice among many, which holds good in certain frames which we call "Inertial frames of reference". In that way, one can construct any set of laws for any set of frames. Are laws of motion just dependent on what coordinates we choose. Do we not have frame independent laws of motion ?
 
In Newtonian physics, Newton's laws, if we include "fictitious forces" in them, are valid in all frames, inertial or not.

In relativity, Newton's laws aren't the correct laws anyway. The correct laws in relativity are valid in all frames, inertial or not.
 
PeterDonis said:
In Newtonian physics, Newton's laws, if we include "fictitious forces" in them, are valid in all frames, inertial or not.

In relativity, Newton's laws aren't the correct laws anyway. The correct laws in relativity are valid in all frames, inertial or not.
Sir, my question was basically, can we have such laws of physics which hold good in all reference frames without introducing extra terms. If yes, what are those laws ?
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
Sir, my question was basically, can we have such laws of physics which hold good in all reference frames without introducing extra terms.
I don't know what you mean by "extra terms". The laws are what they are. I have already stated in post #2 that yes, the correct laws are valid in all frames.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: FactChecker and Sushmit Nandy
PeterDonis said:
I don't know what you mean by "extra terms". The laws are what they are. I have already stated in post #2 that yes, the correct laws are valid in all frames.

PeterDonis said:
I don't know what you mean by "extra terms". The laws are what they are. I have already stated in post #2 that yes, the correct laws are valid in all
PeterDonis said:
I don't know what you mean by "extra terms". The laws are what they are. I have already stated in post #2 that yes, the correct laws are valid in all frames.
Sir, I mean, Newton’s laws can work if we introduce fictious forces. But if we limit ourselves to forces that can be detected by an accelerometer as real forces and claim that all forces which cannot be detected by an accelerometer as fictious, then do we get the correct laws of physics ?
 
Sushmit Nandy said:
Newton’s laws can work if we introduce fictious forces.
Within a limited domain, yes.

Sushmit Nandy said:
if we limit ourselves to forces that can be detected by an accelerometer as real forces and claim that all forces which cannot be detected by an accelerometer as fictious, then do we get the correct laws of physics ?
If you use relativity, sure, because that's exactly how relativity treats forces: only forces that are detectable by an accelerometer are real forces. Which means that gravity is not a real force, since, as Einstein observed in 1907, a body falling freely, solely under the influence of gravity, will not feel its own weight--meaning an accelerometer attached to it will read zero. So the laws of General Relativity are exactly the laws you describe.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy and Dale
Sushmit Nandy said:
Sir, my question was basically, can we have such laws of physics which hold good in all reference frames without introducing extra terms. If yes, what are those laws ?
You can have universally (ignoring relativity) usable laws by including terms that account for non-inertial frames. In inertial frames, those included terms are zero, and the results are Newton's laws.
IMO, it is much more intellectually satisfying to start with inertial reference frames and Newton's laws, which are relatively simple and intuitive, than to start with non-inertial frames and significantly more complicated, non-intuitive laws.
Look at Euler's 6 Degree Of Freedom (DOF) Equations of Motion (EOM) to see how complicated it can get.
For example, suppose a fighter pilot is flying straight and level, at Mach 1 with a reference frame centered in his head and axis of 'out his nose', 'out his left ear', 'out the top of his head'. That is not an inertial frame because he can turn his head and his associated reference frame rotates with it. If he turns his head to the right, that 1 Mach of speed 'out his nose' gets translated to 1 Mach 'out his left ear'. All with no associated forces being applied. The equations and results are not intuitive. Alternatively, in an inertial reference frame, nothing has happened at all.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy
Sushmit Nandy said:
Do we not have frame independent laws of motion ?
We do. But the math for them is not what you see in an intro class. The frame independent law is $$F^\mu = \frac{dP^\mu}{d\tau}$$ where ##F^\mu## is the four-force, ##P^\mu## is the four-momentum, and ##\tau## is the proper time.

This law holds regardless of the coordinate system. All of the extra terms described above are inside these quantities.

Sushmit Nandy said:
Newton’s laws can work if we introduce fictious forces
Not really. Fictitious forces fix Newton’s 2nd law. But they break Newton’s 3rd law.

The law I posted above is a version of Newton’s 2nd that works without breaking Newton’s 3rd.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Sushmit Nandy and FactChecker