Asking the Prof to be a research assistant

  • Thread starter Thread starter Winzer
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Research
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the experiences and expectations of students serving as research assistants (RAs) and teaching assistants (TAs) in academic settings, particularly in physics and engineering. Participants share their personal experiences, concerns about abilities, and the nature of tasks involved in these roles.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant inquires about the typical responsibilities of RAs and expresses concern about their own abilities to contribute effectively.
  • Another participant asks professors what they expect from their assistants, seeking clarity on expectations.
  • A participant shares their experience working as an RA, detailing tasks such as soldering, data collection, and programming, while noting their initial lack of experience in relevant skills.
  • Concerns are raised about the workload of TAs, with questions about whether the stated 20 hours per week is a formal requirement or if actual commitments often exceed or fall short of this expectation.
  • Some participants suggest that professors are generally understanding of students' varying skill levels and are willing to provide guidance and support as students learn.
  • One participant reflects on the balance between the demands of TA and RA roles, noting the potential for greater flexibility in RA positions compared to the structured schedule of TAs.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of experiences and expectations regarding RA and TA roles, indicating that there is no consensus on the workload or responsibilities, as these can vary significantly based on individual professors and specific assignments.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations in their own experiences, such as varying levels of prior knowledge and the specific demands of different professors, which may affect their ability to perform tasks effectively.

Who May Find This Useful

Students considering or currently in RA or TA positions, as well as professors looking to understand student perspectives on these roles.

Winzer
Messages
597
Reaction score
0
So for those of you whom are assistants for your prof what exactly do you do? I plan to really get to know my prof this summer (summer field session for engineering physics majors) and eventually offer my services that could be of use to him. They don't mind do they? But I am scared I may lack some abilities. That is why I would like examples of what exactly yu do as an assistant, thanks.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Also, for the profs out there, what o you expect from your assistant?
Thanks again
 
I have been working (i.e. getting paid) for my prof since summer. First I worked at the physics lab, doing stuff like soldering, hooking up cables, taking sample data and measuring signal-to-noise ratios. Nothing fancy.

Last quarter and the one before that I worked on my professor's website for his project. Basically built it from the ground up. This quarter he gave me some code that calculates a form factor for the cavity in his particle detector (essentially how efficiently a particle can be detected depending on where it is in the cavity and at what frequency the cavity is at) and I need to figure out how it does it to make sure there's no errors in there, and then I have to update it with the parameters for the new cavity.

So it's interesting stuff for me. I had no experience in HTML when I started doing the website, rudimentary experience in electronics, and only a quarter of C++ before doing the coding project. He wasn't bothered by it.

Before that, I did independent research (for free) for a different prof and I worked on his muon detector thing that he was making. Unfortunately, we couldn't get the damn thing to work because of a leak, so I spent like over 2 months trying to fix that leak before I finally got the go-ahead to smother epoxy over it like I had originally suggested.

It wasn't nearly as interesting, but it was still pretty fun.
 
Sorry a bit off topic but still related to assistanship-related issue as a graduate student.
What is it like doing a 20 hrs/week teaching assistanship, is it relatively a heavy work load?
Is that 20 hrs/week relatively standard or below or above standard?
In reality, is that number of hours just for formality, that is, the actual number of hours a TA typically has to commit his/her duty can be much longer if not shorter than that?
I am supposing TA is much less preferrable than RA because with RA we don't have to follow the strict unpleasant hours of undergrad class schedule, do we?
I am hoping for comments particularly from those of you guys/ladies who have real experience of becoming a TA.

Thanks in advance.
 
Winzer,

Most profs expect you to show up, work hard, and be careful in the lab. They understand that your abilities are limited by your coursework and experience to date. In one research position, the prof gave me a programming task that was a bit beyond me. When I couldn't do it, he did it himself and gave me some simpler tasks without getting mad about it. Eventually my programming skills grew and I was able to complete the more complex programming tasks he gave me.

In an experimental lab, there are lots of mundane tasks, often involving vacuum systems or electronics. The profs don't mind showing you how to do stuff, but pay careful attention so that you don't have to be shown twice. Be willing to read the manual for equipment and use outside resources so that you don't take too much of the prof's time asking for repeated explanations.

You don't have to be a whiz at everything in the lab, but find a few things where you can really contribute. The bottom line for prof's regarding undergraduates helping in research is that the students are a net gain for the lab. You must save the prof and grad students more time and effort than they expend showing you stuff. You must show up regularly (on time), work hard, and grow in your abilities.

Be sure and take your prof's advice. If he wants you to take an electronics course or a programming course, do it.

I found a lot of mercy, kindness, and patience for my lack of abilities. But I worked very hard and tried to be dependable. Consequently, my undergraduate research was very fruitful, I was included as a co-author on two papers, I had good recommendations, and graduate schools were beating down my door.

Michael Courtney
 
Urkel said:
Sorry a bit off topic but still related to assistanship-related issue as a graduate student.
What is it like doing a 20 hrs/week teaching assistanship, is it relatively a heavy work load?
Is that 20 hrs/week relatively standard or below or above standard?
In reality, is that number of hours just for formality, that is, the actual number of hours a TA typically has to commit his/her duty can be much longer if not shorter than that?
I am supposing TA is much less preferrable than RA because with RA we don't have to follow the strict unpleasant hours of undergrad class schedule, do we?
I am hoping for comments particularly from those of you guys/ladies who have real experience of becoming a TA.

Thanks in advance.

In my experience, the number of hours is a formality, and the work load depends on the classes you are assigned and the profs teaching the classes. Only the prof can tell you exactly what your responsibilities are, but they usually include grading most (or all) of the student work, preparing solutions for homework, and perhaps setting some time aside (office hours) to help students with homework. I think I made a pretty good impression by writing up the solutions in LaTex for one course I TA'd.

I liked my RA because it got me into the research group where I completed my PhD research. However, I really learned a lot in my TA position because the prof was a great teacher and I used the opportunity to grow in my teaching skills by trying to understand the big picture of course design and delivery. The prof conveyed great enthusiasm for teaching physics and I was able to pick up on some of that.

Michael Courtney
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 21 ·
Replies
21
Views
5K
Replies
23
Views
5K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 25 ·
Replies
25
Views
6K
Replies
1
Views
2K