• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products Here!

Basic Forces Question (Piano Slides Across Floor)

  • #1
174
0

Homework Statement


A piano slides across a floor with a mass of 500kg.

A) solve for the normal force
B) A horizontal force 1300 is necessary to keep it in motion at constant speed find the coefficient of friction


Homework Equations



Fnet = MA

The Attempt at a Solution



Given: m= 500kg , fnetx=1300N


fnety= FN - FG = 0
Fn=Fg
FN=4900 N upward

b) fnetx = max = 1300N = -FFR
(i made my +x opposite the force of friction)

1300N = -FFR
1300 = mu*FN
mu = 1300/FN
mu = 1300/4900
mu= 0.265

Now a question arises...

I understand that ax must be 0 because it is at a constant velocity...

But i'm just curious because FFR = Fnetx

That means FFR= 1300N

So doesn't this mean that this unbalanced force will slow down the piano and not keep it at a constant motion? Anyways Yea i would appreciate some help please.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
172
2
1300N is not Fnetx. A force of 1300N is applied in the x-direction, and a friction force of 1300N is applied in the negative x-direction. Fnetx is the resultant of these two forces, and since they're equal/opposite forces, the resultant force is 0.
 
  • #3
174
0
1300N is not Fnetx. A force of 1300N is applied in the x-direction, and a friction force of 1300N is applied in the negative x-direction. Fnetx is the resultant of these two forces, and since they're equal/opposite forces, the resultant force is 0.
So how can that be right if the net force is 0, that means that the forces are balanced, therefore the object must be at rest.

IE: FNETY=FN-FG=0 this proves an object stationary in the vertical direction

So if Fnetx= Fa - FFr = 0

Therefore the object cannot moving horizontally because there is no imbalanced force? It would be at rest..

Also to note.

If FA = FFR

Therefore 1300 = Mu*FN
Mu = 1300/FN = 0.265

This yields also, the same answer.


Please further elaborate your answer?

*Also i don't think you can say because they are equal and opposite forces it is equal to zero*

The only thing that implies Fnetx=0 is the fact it says it is uniform velocity.

So therefore Fnetx=m*ax if ax=0 Fnetx = 0
 
Last edited:
  • #4
174
0
:( some one else help me plz?
 
  • #5
172
2
If the net force is 0, that means there is no acceleration (no change in velocity). Whatever initial velocity the object had will be maintained. Presumably, at some point there were imbalanced forces which accelerated the piano to some velocity before the start of the problem.

Your answer should be unaffected by this, and it seems to me that you did everything right otherwise.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
174
0
If the net force is 0, that means there is no acceleration (no change in velocity). Whatever initial velocity the object had will be maintained. Presumably, at some point there were imbalanced forces which accelerated the piano to some velocity before the start of the problem.

Your answer should be unaffected by this, and it seems to me that you did everything right otherwise.
So is it similiar to the property of Inertia, in the sense that you are trying to apply a force strong enough to to compensate for the friction, so that it is almost as if no forces act horizontally? This way in the sense of inertia, the object is still moving at the same velocity, because no "External" force is able to act, because the external force is compensated for?

And also thank you.
 

Related Threads for: Basic Forces Question (Piano Slides Across Floor)

  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
740
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
10K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Top