Discussion Overview
The discussion centers around the search for a comprehensive reference book in pure mathematics that includes worked examples and proof practice, similar to "Formulas and Theorems in Pure Mathematics" by George Shoobridge Carr. Participants are seeking updated resources that cover advanced topics in mathematics.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant describes "Formulas and Theorems" as a compilation of over 6000 formulas and theorems from the late 18th century, seeking a more modern equivalent.
- Another participant questions whether Carr's book was used by Ramanujan for self-study.
- Several participants express interest in finding a modern version of Carr's book or similar comprehensive references.
- A suggestion is made to consider the "Oxford Users' Guide to Mathematics," with a note that it can be previewed on Amazon.
- Another recommendation includes "The Princeton Companion to Mathematics," highlighting its comprehensive nature.
- One participant inquires about the suitability of these books for high school or undergraduate students.
- There is a shared concern about the availability of Carr's book, with one participant noting difficulty in finding it for sale and questioning its current status.
- A later reply mentions that Carr's book is out of copyright and suggests it may be available online.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express a common interest in finding updated reference materials, but there is no consensus on specific titles or their suitability for different educational levels. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the availability of Carr's book.
Contextual Notes
Participants have not reached a conclusion about the best reference book, and there are varying opinions on the appropriateness of suggested titles for different audiences.