Best Ethernet / Network switch setup?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheMacNerd
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Network Switch
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the optimal setup for a Cisco gigabit ethernet/network switch in a home environment, focusing on the arrangement of various devices including a Smart TV, gaming console, desktop PC, and network printer. Participants explore the implications of using the switch for wired connections versus wireless options, as well as the potential for maximizing network efficiency.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant outlines their intended setup, including connecting multiple devices to the switch and expresses uncertainty about its effectiveness.
  • Another participant clarifies that an ethernet switch is necessary for connecting multiple devices, as an ethernet splitter does not exist.
  • A different participant describes the general flow of a network setup, emphasizing the role of the switch as an expander for ethernet ports.
  • Some participants suggest that the proposed setup is adequate for achieving high transfer rates between devices, provided they support gigabit speeds.
  • Concerns are raised about the efficiency of the switch, with one participant questioning how to best utilize it for optimal performance.
  • Another participant notes that the switch can be programmed for advanced features, depending on its model, and requests the model number for further analysis.
  • One participant emphasizes the importance of connecting devices that generate significant LAN traffic directly to the switch, while suggesting that devices primarily using internet connections can be connected elsewhere.
  • There is a caution regarding the switch being unmanaged, with a mention of negative reviews about its performance and limitations.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the necessity of using an ethernet switch for connecting multiple devices, but there are differing opinions on the efficiency and capabilities of the specific Cisco model discussed. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best practices for utilizing the switch effectively.

Contextual Notes

Some participants mention limitations of the switch, including its unmanaged nature and mixed reviews regarding its performance. There are also unresolved questions about the specific features available based on the model number provided.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for individuals setting up home networks, particularly those interested in optimizing the use of ethernet switches and understanding the implications of device connections.

TheMacNerd
Messages
74
Reaction score
18
My grandma recently gave me a relatively new Cisco gigabit ethernet / network switch because she never used it.
Here are the devices that need to be wired:

Here is the current setup:

Internet / Wifi Modem upstairs, my bedroom / "tech studio" is in the downstairs / basement of the townhouse. There's a shop in the basement with two benches with 4 wall outlets each. I was thinking after I clear a space I could put a high-end PC or Mac Workstation there with Ubuntu Linux / Mac OS X.

In my basement, there is an ethernet cable and HDMI Cable coming out of the wall where my Smart TV will be.

The Cisco Network Switch has 8 Ports. I have wireless USB adapters / dongles for my desktop PC I own.

- Smart TV (getting it for this XMas)
- XBox360 Game console
- SATA Hard disk drives (Multiple) (after I purchase the enclosures) (to use as SAN/NAS) (hooked to the switch & the modem)
- Maybe? a desktop PC/ Mac Pro Workstation (in the shop area)
- A network HP Color Printer

More information to know:

The basement / bedroom I have is 1/2 finished. I'm staying in the finished 1/2 where my current desktop PC & laptop for school are. The ethernet cable is coming out of the finished 1/2 of the basement where my Smart TV & Xbox360 will be. When I moved the cable installer technician reccomended if we don't already have one, an ethernet splitter.

I want the ethernet switch downstairs, in my tech studio / basement. It is acceptable if it goes into the shop area / unfinished section of the basement. The wireless / network printer must be connected to the switch.

Here is what my theory on a setup for me might look like:

On one of the workbenches in the shop area, plug the network / ethernet switch into one of the 4+ wall outlets (I have power strips as well). Plug the printer to the switch, the desktop pc and / or server, as well as the SATA hard drives. The TV can be plug into the cables coming out of my wall. The Xbox plugs to the TV.

Is this a good setup? Or is there something better to suggest?
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Albert Ralph
Computer science news on Phys.org
I do not understand your question. Do you want us to comment on the power connection or the Ethernet connections?
TheMacNerd said:
When I moved the cable installer technician reccomended if we don't already have one, an ethernet splitter.
Sorry, such a device does not exist. In order to connect several networked devices together, you need an Ethernet switch (like the Cisco switch you mentioned).
TheMacNerd said:
The Cisco Network Switch has 8 Ports. I have wireless USB adapters / dongles for my desktop PC I own.
Yes, but I doubt that the Cisco has any Wi-Fi interface.
TheMacNerd said:
On one of the workbenches in the shop area, plug the network / ethernet switch into one of the 4+ wall outlets (I have power strips as well). Plug the printer to the switch, the desktop pc and / or server, as well as the SATA hard drives. The TV can be plug into the cables coming out of my wall. The Xbox plugs to the TV.
A drawing would help...
 
I can't following what you are describing.

The general setup is Cable/DSL Modem <-> WiFi and Router <-> Ethernet devices. One of the ethernet devices can be the ethernet switch, which will give you more Ethernet ports.
(an Ethernet Switch is essentially an ethernet expander or splitter, although it is more complicated than a simple splitter)

The parts may move around, for example the WiFi part could be implemented within the Modem. Or, even the Router/WiFi/Modem could be one unit. But the basic flow is I indicated.
 
Yeah, your network setup is fine. Your PCs and the NAS are on the same gigabit switch so you will have the highest possible transfer rates between your large storage devices (assuming the NICs on the devices also support gigabit speeds)
You may stream media from the NAS to the TV but streaming won't be able to saturate that gigabit link. Even if your router only does fast ethernet (100mbps) your smartTV and Xbox won't notice any difference.

The only time you will see any significant effect of not having gigabit is if you are doing large simultaneous transfers across multiple systems (we're talking 10s or 100s of GB)
Outside of that, it doesn't really matter how you setup the network inside your home. The average user never really goes that much over 10mbps, your average 1080p video on youtube just needs around 7-9mbps to run without pauses for buffering.

Long story short, the way you plan to plug things is is fine. Just avoid wifi if possible. Wired connections are always superior.
 
I'm just wondering the most effecient way to use the ethernet switch. That's my question.
 
The switch provides, at its simplest, a way to turn 1 long cable run into many ethernet ports.

They also can be programmed to setup subnets and such if you need to isolate sub networks.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_switch

What is the model number of your switch?

Draw a diagram of the network, or the network you want, and we can comment on use of the switch.

For example, from the wikipedia article, you switch MIGHT (or might not) support such features as:

 
Cisco SG100D-08
 
TheMacNerd said:
I'm just wondering the most effecient way to use the ethernet switch. That's my question.
You want as many devices as possible connected directly into the gigabit switch, prioritise devices that generate the most LAN traffic. By this I mean, devices within your own home that send large files to each other, not downloading/uploading from the internet. Like your fileserver & computers.

Devices that will not be transferring data between devices at home (like Xbox/Playstation, smart TV, etc.) can go anywhere. These devices exchange data almost exclusively with the internet (downloading games/updates, netflx, etc.) and will top out at your internet connection's speed, gigabit link is irrelevant.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Silicon Waffle
It's an unmanaged switch, so none of the features I mentioned are available.

In addition, Cisco has gotten bad reviews for this switch on Amazon, in that all ports are not gigabit.

You should read the Amazon reviews, and the product manual.

Think of it as a simple ethernet hub. One port to many, with some limitations as described in the reviews.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
6K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
20K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 43 ·
2
Replies
43
Views
6K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
4K