Bizarre Aptitude Test Results: Magician & Garbage Collector?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lisab
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Collector Test
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the peculiar results of aptitude tests taken by various individuals, highlighting the unexpected and often humorous career suggestions generated by these tests. Participants share their own experiences with such tests, questioning their validity and relevance in determining suitable career paths.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants recount their own aptitude test results, which include unconventional careers like "magician," "feng shui designer," "garbage collector," and "vending machine installer."
  • One participant expresses skepticism about the ability of a single test to accurately assess a person's suitability for a career, emphasizing the importance of work ethic, drive, and passion.
  • Another participant questions the legitimacy of the test that includes "feng shui designer," suggesting it leans more towards fortune telling than actual aptitude assessment.
  • Several participants share humorous takes on the absurdity of the tests, including sarcastic suggestions about the types of questions that might be asked.
  • Discussions about the roles of theoretical and experimental philosophers arise, with participants humorously debating the nature of these professions and their relevance.
  • Some participants reflect on their past experiences with similar tests in high school, noting a general lack of seriousness and accuracy in the results.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally share a skepticism towards the validity of aptitude tests, with multiple competing views on their usefulness and accuracy. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the effectiveness of such tests in guiding career choices.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include a lack of empirical evidence supporting the claims about the tests' effectiveness, as well as varying definitions of what constitutes a suitable career based on personal attributes beyond test results.

Who May Find This Useful

Individuals interested in career guidance, psychology of testing, or those reflecting on their own educational experiences may find this discussion relevant.

lisab
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
2,050
Reaction score
612
I just talked to my sister-in-law in Texas. Her son took an aptitude test recently...his top two jobs (I swear, I couldn't make this up!):

1. Magician,
2. Feng shui designer.

I told this to my daughter, for a laugh. She said, "OMG (she is 15, after all)! I think we took the same test last year. I got:

1. Garbage collector,
2. Vending machine installer!"

Anyone else familiar with these bizarre aptitude tests?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
LOL I thought those only existed as plot-devices in cheesy TV shows.

I'd love to take one. I can see my results now:

1. International secret agent who single-handedly thwarts evil for the good of man-kind.
2. Fat nerd.
 
I took one called the KISS, but it told me what I already knew, that I want to be a scientist.
 
I can't believe there are people that take these things seriously. How could one test, ONE TEST, determine whether you are fit to do something. A person is defined not only by their natural ability to do math, english, science, etc. but also by there work ethic, drive, and passion. How can one test take into account those aspects?

I thought we were beyond this as a society, seriously! Anyway, I better get back to studying for the GRE...
 
Mine was, man who works for big headed mouthy butler in bygone days or unlucky king.
 
The mere fact that this test has ‘Feng shui designer’ listed as a profession makes me think it might be more on the fortune telling side of things rather than something that actually determines someone's aptitudes. What kind of questions would the test have asked your nephew to determine that he has a sensitivity to the harmonious flow of chi?
 
CaptainQuasar said:
What kind of questions would the test have asked your nephew to determine that he has a sensitivity to the harmonious flow of chi?

A) Can you keep a straight face while ripping people off Y/N
B) Do you want to spend years at law school learning how to do (A) Y/N
 
OMG! They still have those things? When I was in high school, the guidance counselors made us all take one of those tests to help us identify future careers. We all had a great laugh about them...yeah, our results were about like those you gave and about as accurate. I don't know where they got those tests from or why they thought we needed to use them. They seem to be geared to the completely clueless kid who doesn't want to admit they're going to choose a "career" after high school by throwing darts at the want ads.
 
mgb_phys said:
A) Can you keep a straight face while ripping people off Y/N
B) Do you want to spend years at law school learning how to do (A) Y/N

HA :smile:
 
  • #10
gazes into crystal ball❊ I see… a tall, dark stranger in your future. No! Many tall dark strangers. And they are chasing you. With torches and pitchforks.
 
  • #11
I remember taking something like this in high school. I remember one of my results was "mime".

Oddly enough, most of my friends were also destined to be mimes.
 
  • #12
I was told told I would make a good theoretical philosopher. I don't even know what a philosopher does and do they even get paid for doing it?
 
  • #13
lisab said:
I just talked to my sister-in-law in Texas. Her son took an aptitude test recently...his top two jobs (I swear, I couldn't make this up!):

1. Magician,
2. Feng shui designer.

I told this to my daughter, for a laugh. She said, "OMG (she is 15, after all)! I think we took the same test last year. I got:

1. Garbage collector,
2. Vending machine installer!"

Anyone else familiar with these bizarre aptitude tests?

I'm sure your daughter is a wonderful child, but I'm wondering how many questions she could have gotten right to end up in the garbage collector category. I think you only have to get your name right to be bumped into the fast food industry category.
 
  • #14
tribdog said:
I was told told I would make a good theoretical philosopher. I don't even know what a philosopher does and do they even get paid for doing it?

My question for the people who told you this would be, not "What does a theoretical philosopher do?" but instead..."What does an experimental philosopher do?!"
 
  • #15
G01 said:
"What does a theoretical philosopher do?"
Presumably spends all their time answering the question "What does a theoretical philosopher do?"
 
  • #16
mgb_phys said:
Presumably spends all their time answering the question "What does a theoretical philosopher do?"

I still think the question of what an experimental philosopher does is much more important. Have you ever seen an experiment confirming a philosophical theory??

Seriously, what do they do?:rolleyes:
 
  • #17
Theoretical philosopher= master of the art of bullsh!it, required training includes getting a BS. Experimental philosopher sounds like the professional name for the lysergic acid and psyoclibin tester.
 
  • #18
binzing said:
Theoretical philosopher= master of the art of bullsh!it, required training includes getting a BS.

oh my gosh, they were right.
 
  • #19
G01 said:
I still think the question of what an experimental philosopher does is much more important. Have you ever seen an experiment confirming a philosophical theory??

Seriously, what do they do?:rolleyes:
If you read Terry Pratchett you would know - picture Xeno's axiom testing centre with lots of tortoises with arrows through them, which logically they should have been able to outrun.
 
  • #20
tribdog said:
oh my gosh, they were right.

Who is they and what were "they" right about?
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Replies
42
Views
8K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
7K
  • · Replies 24 ·
Replies
24
Views
4K
  • · Replies 65 ·
3
Replies
65
Views
12K