BONG Man grows tree in lung. BONG

  • Thread starter Thread starter neu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Tree
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around a reported case of a fir tree section being removed from a man's lung, with participants sharing personal anecdotes related to unusual objects found in body parts. The conversation touches on themes of medical anomalies, humor, and anecdotal experiences.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Some participants express skepticism about the validity of the reported case, suggesting it may be a joke or sensationalized story.
  • Several anecdotes are shared about unusual items found in ears or noses, including a kernel of corn and a dry pinto bean, highlighting personal experiences with similar situations.
  • One participant recounts a story involving a bee getting stuck in a friend's ear, drawing a parallel to the original post.
  • Another participant mentions a historical torture method involving a centipede-like creature being placed in the ear, adding a darker context to the discussion.
  • There is a mix of disbelief and humor regarding the possibility of such occurrences, with some participants questioning the plausibility of the original claim.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally do not agree on the credibility of the original story, with some viewing it as a joke while others share personal anecdotes that suggest similar phenomena can occur. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the authenticity of the reported case.

Contextual Notes

Some participants express uncertainty about the medical implications of such occurrences and the conditions under which they might happen. The discussion includes anecdotal evidence that may not be representative of broader medical knowledge.

Who May Find This Useful

Readers interested in medical anomalies, humorous personal anecdotes, or discussions about unusual biological occurrences may find this thread engaging.

neu
Messages
228
Reaction score
3
A five centimetre section of fir tree has been removed from a man's lung, Russian surgeons claim.

Doctors were investigating a suspected tumour in Artyom Sidorkin's lung, when they were surprised by a very different kind of trouble.

Surgeon Vladimir Kamashev said he was astonished, but botanist Olga Baranova was sceptical. Juliet Dunlop reports.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/8000745.stm
 
Biology news on Phys.org
I had an uncle who had a kernel of corn sprout in his ear.
 
WTF?

Haha.
 
physics girl phd said:
I had an uncle who had a kernel of corn sprout in his ear.

Yeah whatever, like that is even possible.
 
My mom (one of eight) grew up on a farm; and my dad (the oldest of eight) grew up in the city. When they were engaged, my mom's parents hosted a party for both sides. My dad's youngest brother (maybe 13 at the time?) had perhaps too much fun playing in the barns / grain bin, and he didn't realize he got a kernel deep in his ear (if you have young sons you might understand this obliviousness part). A few weeks later he got a terrible headache/earache. The moist (probably not-often inspected) environment of his ear was perfect for growth. I'm not sure how the doctor cleared it all out, even though it was probably quite small at the time. I just know he didn't like to talk about it, while my grandma and my aunts/other uncles used to bring it up quite frequently.
 
There is no evidence that this man smokes what has been repeated twice in the title for the sole purpose of provocation and advertising. The OP does not have evidence for that. As for the story itself, it's merely a joke.
 
physics girl phd said:
I had an uncle who had a kernel of corn sprout in his ear.
When I was a kid. A friend and I were hoeing weeds out of a bean field when he had a sweet bee get into his ear. The insect couldn't get turned around inorder to get out. It took me quite a while with a probe trying to get it out while all the time its buzzing drove my friend nuts. I'll never forget the panic in his eyes. LOL
 
dlgoff said:
When I was a kid. A friend and I were hoeing weeds out of a bean field when he had a sweet bee get into his ear. The insect couldn't get turned around inorder to get out. It took me quite a while with a probe trying to get it out while all the time its buzzing drove my friend nuts. I'll never forget the panic in his eyes. LOL
If you'd ever seen the film Mountains of the Moon, you wouldn't be LOLing.

It takes place in the wilds of Africa. One of the characters falls asleep with his bedside lamp lit and forgets his mosquito netting. Beetles come.

In his pain, he opts for relief from burrowing over keeping his hearing, and grabs a pick...

:eek:
 
In southern India, they used a form of torture like that a few hundred years ago.

They would take a small centipede, like creature, oil it up and drop it into the ear of a person unable to move their head. It was used mainly as a interrogation technique.
 
  • #10
neu said:
Yeah whatever, like that is even possible.

Cripes! Haven't you ever heard of an ear of corn?
 
  • #11
I had a dry pinto bean in my nose when I was a little kid. I don't recall how old I was, but I was old enough to not want to tell anyone, because I was embarrassed. But my nose started to swell by evening, and I had to confess.
Yes it was removed and I have no bean plant growing out of my nose.
 
  • #12
That reminds me of one of our great family episodes: My little brother got Fred Flintstone stuck in his nose. There was nothing to do but wait for the purple vitamin to melt and ooze out.