Programs BS MSE + Math OR Physics Minor?

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the value of pursuing a minor in physics or math while studying for a BS in Materials Engineering. The original poster expresses a desire for deeper theoretical knowledge and challenging problems, indicating an interest in both subjects. Responses suggest that while a minor can enhance learning, it typically holds little weight in graduate school admissions or job qualifications. Instead of committing to a minor, participants recommend taking electives that align with personal interests and career goals. The blend of physics and materials science is highlighted as beneficial, emphasizing the importance of practical application alongside theoretical understanding. Overall, the consensus leans towards prioritizing relevant coursework over formal minors.
Copar
Messages
11
Reaction score
1
I am studying to get a BS in Materials Engineering. I am learning a ton of useful skills (MATLAB, spectroscopy, materials testing), but I miss the theory in the math / physics classes I took during my first couple of years.

I don't know if I would like physics or math more, I like them both. I do want a minor though, just for the sake of learning and doing more challenging problems. What do you think?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm not sure what you're looking for in terms of an answer. If you want a minor, then go for it. If you're trying to decide between a minor in physics or math, a lot depends on what you find more appealing and what you want to do in the future. Just bear in mind that a minor doesn't really tend to qualify you for much. Most graduate schools won't accept someone based on a minor.
 
Copar said:
I am studying to get a BS in Materials Engineering. I am learning a ton of useful skills (MATLAB, spectroscopy, materials testing), but I miss the theory in the math / physics classes I took during my first couple of years.

I don't know if I would like physics or math more, I like them both. I do want a minor though, just for the sake of learning and doing more challenging problems. What do you think?
I've never understood the point in getting a minor vs. just taking electives that you find useful or interesting. As a credential on a resume, a minor really has little (or no) value..

FWIW, I got my bachelor's, masters, and PhD in physics, specializing in solid-state physics. I took the math required for the physics programs. But I took almost all my free electives (both undergrad and grad) in materials science and engineering (MSE); the math required for the physics programs met or exceeded the math required for the MSE electives. The blend between the fundamental approach of physics and the pragmatic approach of MSE was a good combo, at least for me.
 
  • Like
Likes jasonRF and gwnorth
I agree with @CrysPhys, unless your school requires you to complete a minor, a minor in and of itself has no real intrinsic value. Just take whatever electives that you want, whether they be math or physics.
 
Given the current funding situation, you should contact potential departments or research groups before you apply and pay any application fees. Many programs are not taking new graduate students at all this cycle because of funding uncertainty, unless a specific advisor can show they already have money to support you for five years. This is what I’ve heard directly from 20–30 programs. Do not waste money applying blindly.