Button click event image hiding is delayed

[Bob Walance]

TL;DR

The style.visibility = 'hidden' image attribute is not taking effect until end of sleep function

My webpage project has a button labeled 'Harmonics' with a mouse-click event. I want an image to be hidden as soon as the button is clicked, however this doesn't happen.

Here's a snippet of the html. It doesn't matter what order the two Javascript functions are called. The 'hidden' attribute for the image does not take effect until the sleep function completes.

gwd.Harmonics = function(event) {
document.getElementsByClassName('gwd-img-17a0')[0].style.visibility = 'hidden'; // hide the image
sleep(2000); // delay for 2000ms

Can anyone tell me if this can be fixed so that the image is hidden as soon as the button is clicked?

 

[PeterDonis]

Why is the sleep function there at all?

 

[Bob Walance]

Why is the sleep function there at all?

I'm just using a sleep function here to simply demonstrate the issue. The real project is playing a tone and I need to know when the tone has ended. There is an event-driven mechanism for this but it is unreliable so I'm using a simple date/time-based timer in order to know when to start the next tone.

 

[PeterDonis]

I'm just using a sleep function here to simply demonstrate the issue.

Unfortunately, the issue you are running up against, at least as I understand how the Javascript engine works, is simple: your function is an event handler and Javascript doesn't update the browser display to reflect any changes the event handler makes until after the handler returns. So you can't put any kind of time delay tracking mechanism in an event handler because it delays updating the browser display.

There is an event-driven mechanism for this but it is unreliable

How so?

 

[Bob Walance]

Unfortunately, the issue you are running up against, at least as I understand how the Javascript engine works, is simple: your function is an event handler and Javascript doesn't update the browser display to reflect any changes the event handler makes until after the handler returns. So you can't put any kind of time delay tracking mechanism in an event handler because it delays updating the browser display.

How so?

1 - I was afraid of that. That's really how it appears to be behaving. Darn.
2 - I think that the audioContext tone generation 'onend' event issue is related to "Javascript doesn't update the browser display..." operation that you pointed out.

My app's purpose is to demonstrate the difference, musically, between equal-temperament tuning and simple harmonics of an instrument note (nature). The part of the app that plays one tone or chord works perfectly. When I need a sequence of tones (e.g. in a musical scale) then I run into these issues.

I have a complete application written and working in Python, but I can't distribute the Python code here. That's why I'm attempting to get it to work in a web browser.

 

[pbuk]

2 - I think that the audioContext tone generation 'onend' event issue is related to "Javascript doesn't update the browser display..." operation that you pointed out.

There is no AudioContext onend event. Perhaps you are thinking of the AudioScheduledSourceNode ended event: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/AudioScheduledSourceNode/ended_event

My app's purpose is to demonstrate the difference, musically, between equal-temperament tuning and simple harmonics of an instrument note (nature). The part of the app that plays one tone or chord works perfectly. When I need a sequence of tones (e.g. in a musical scale) then I run into these issues.

Perhaps you might be better off using the tone.js module I showed you on another thread.

I have a complete application written and working in Python, but I can't distribute the Python code here. That's why I'm attempting to get it to work in a web browser.

Programming for the web is very different from programming in Python, you need to completely change your mindset to write asynchronous, event driven code rather than the blocking code you are used to.

 

[jedishrfu]

Maybe this will work:

https://www.codegrepper.com/code-ex...+to+reload+page+on+button+click+in+javascript

It's likely an ugly solution, but from it, you might find a better way.

 

[Bob Walance]

There is no AudioContext onend event. Perhaps you are thinking of the AudioScheduledSourceNode ended event: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/AudioScheduledSourceNode/
Perhaps you might be better off using the tone.js module I showed you on another thread.

Programming for the web is very different from programming in Python, you need to completely change your mindset to write asynchronous, event driven code rather than the blocking code you are used to.

There is no AudioContext onend event. Perhaps you are thinking of the AudioScheduledSourceNode ended event: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/AudioScheduledSourceNode/ended_eventPerhaps you might be better off using the tone.js module I showed you on another thread.Programming for the web is very different from programming in Python, you need to completely change your mindset to write asynchronous, event driven code rather than the blocking code you are used to.

I did look at tone.js but I don't think it'll do what I want. For example, I need to play two major chords:
A + C# + E
and
440Hz + 550Hz + 660Hz

They both sound close but the latter is much sweeter sounding. The beat frequency produced between the C# and the fifth harmonic of 110Hz is very obvious when it's juxtaposed with the natural major third interval.

 

[Bob Walance]

Maybe this will work:

https://www.codegrepper.com/code-ex...+to+reload+page+on+button+click+in+javascript

It's likely an ugly solution, but from it, you might find a better way.

Thanks. I'm aware of this and am utilizing it to make repeated musical scales more reliable (I'm not sure where the real issue is there).

I should have been a software engineer. Their life is SO much easier overall. They can just sit at their computers all day sipping their Daiquiris while us EEs have to go into the lab and inhale lead fumes.

 

[jedishrfu]

Sadly, you have a romanticized view of software engineers. Yes, we can code but a lot of time is spent tracking down your own or other people's misguided coding mistakes, and some can be downright impossible to find in a timely fashion.

So revel in the fact that you are a talented engineer learning the ropes of programming.

 

[I like Serena]

There is actually no sleep function in javascript. And if you keep javascript busy in a different fashion, all other activity is on hold as @PeterDonis already pointed out. Moreover, if you keep javascript busy for too long (a couple of seconds), the browser will complain that a script is causing trouble and ask if you want to kill it.

If you do want to sleep, then the relevant function is setTimeout, which takes a callback that will be called after a time. During this time all other activity resumes and the browser will display anything that was changed.

If you want to wait for it and continue what you were doing, then you can use:

function sleep(ms) {
    return new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, ms));
}
gwd.Harmonics = async function(event) {
  document.getElementsByClassName('gwd-img-17a0')[0].style.visibility = 'hidden'; // hide the image
  await sleep(2000); // delay for 2000ms
  // Other processing
}

Note that the sleep is implemented using setTimeout, and all other activity will resume during this time so your element will immediately become invisible.

 

[Bob Walance]

If you want to wait for it and continue what you were doing, then you can use:

function sleep(ms) {
    return new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, ms));
}
gwd.Harmonics = async function(event) {
  document.getElementsByClassName('gwd-img-17a0')[0].style.visibility = 'hidden'; // hide the image
  await sleep(2000); // delay for 2000ms
  // Other processing
}

Note that the sleep is implemented using setTimeout, and all other activity will resume during this time so your element will immediately become invisible.

YES! Your solution works perfectly. I was just about to give up and try a different approach, but you completely solved my problem.

Thank you very much, liker of Serena.