Calculate Earth's Angular Momentum in Solar Orbit

[MissEuropa]

Homework Statement

A)Calculate the magnitude of the angular momentum of the Earth in a circular orbit around the sun.

B) Is it reasonable to model it as a particle?
Yes, considering the size of the Earth in comparison of its orbit around the sun it is reasonable to model it is a particle.

Homework Equations

L = I*ω (when considering the Earth as a rigid body)
L=r*p
I=m_E*r_E

The Attempt at a Solution

Assuming the Earth has a completely circular orbit:
The Earth's orbit is 2∏ radians, it completes this orbit in one year.
1 year = 3.145*10⁷ s
2∏/3.156*10⁷ = 1.99*10^-7rad/s
Average linear speed = ω*r (radius of orbit which is 1AU or 1.49*10¹¹
(1.99*10⁷)*(1.49*10¹¹)=2.977*10¹⁸m/s

So, using the formula L=r x p
(1.49*10¹¹)*(2.977*10¹⁸)*sin90°=4.45*10²⁹m^2/s

But, this was not the answer masteringphysics was looking for.

So, using the formula L=Iω
I calculated I (mass of the Earth*radius) = (3.81*10³¹)*(1.99*10^-7) = 7.58*10²⁴ kg*m²/s

And that's also not the answer masteringphysics was looking for.
I'm not sure if I made a mistake somewhere in my calculations or if I'm not using the right values for mass, radius of Earth etc. Because Earth's orbit is non circular I'm not sure at what point in Earth's orbit they wanted us to consider as the radius. I choose one AU because it's an averaged value.

Thoughts?

 

[tms]

Average linear speed = ω*r (radius of orbit which is 1AU or 1.49*10¹¹
(1.99*10⁷)*(1.49*10¹¹)=2.977*10¹⁸m/s

Always check your answers for sanity. What is the speed of light? This number is obviously wrong. In fact, it is exactly 14 orders of magnitude wrong. That should give you a hint.

 

[D H]

Assuming the Earth has a completely circular orbit:
The Earth's orbit is 2∏ radians, it completes this orbit in one year.
1 year = 3.145*10⁷ s
2∏/3.156*10⁷ = 1.99*10^-7rad/s
Average linear speed = ω*r (radius of orbit which is 1AU or 1.49*10¹¹
(1.99*10⁷)*(1.49*10¹¹)=2.977*10¹⁸m/s

So, using the formula L=r x p
(1.49*10¹¹)*(2.977*10¹⁸)*sin90°=4.45*10²⁹m^2/s

Momentum has units of mass*velocity or mass*length/time. Angular momentum has units of mass*length²/time. Where's the mass in your answer?

 

[MissEuropa]

Momentum has units of mass*velocity or mass*length/time. Angular momentum has units of mass*length²/time. Where's the mass in your answer?

Just caught that. I'm reworking now and I'll update soon. :-) thanks for the help

 

[MissEuropa]

Congrats!http://www.infoocean.info/avatar1.jpg

Thankies!
So, I started from the beginning again, as not to confuse myself. Calculated the inertia of the Earth (which is why I was missing a mass component in my final answer) and got it right.

Symbolic math is the way to go for the most part, then plugging in numbers afterward.
I ended up with 2.67*10⁴⁰ kg*m²/s

Thanks for the help again.

 

[tms]

Symbolic math is the way to go for the most part, then plugging in numbers afterward.

Absolutely. Most students never seem to learn that.