The discussion explores whether a magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) drive can function without a traditional tube, suggesting that a ship's hull could potentially pull the vessel through water instead. The challenge lies in generating a strong magnetic field, as the tube design typically allows for a controlled magnetic path. Alternatives, such as using a corrugated hull to house magnets, are proposed, but this would still necessitate external electrodes, effectively creating a tube-like structure. Concerns about magnetic materials and hull conductivity are raised, indicating that using iron could direct the magnetic field along the hull, while aluminum could lead to corrosion issues. Overall, the feasibility of an MHD drive without a tube remains complex and problematic.