ajayraho
- 6
- 0
Can an atom exist without any electron? If yes, then how?
An atom cannot exist without electrons in the traditional sense, as the absence of electrons transforms it into an ion. For example, a hydrogen atom can lose its single electron during acid-base reactions, resulting in a proton (H+), which is not classified as an atom. Additionally, in extreme conditions like those found on the surface of the sun, atoms can become fully ionized, existing as plasma. Therefore, while ions and charged particles can exist, they do not meet the definition of an atom.
PREREQUISITESStudents of chemistry, physicists, and anyone interested in the fundamental principles of atomic structure and behavior in different states of matter.
Matter is built out of neutrons, protons(+), and electrons(-). Matter becomes stable only if it is electrically neutral. So atoms without electrons do exist and must have their own states (charged or uncharged) transferred back and forth in their environments.ajayraho said:Can an atom exist without any electron? If yes, then how?
An atom stripped out all of their electrons is called an ion and it's charged. No ions is uncharged.Silicon Waffle said:So atoms without electrons do exist and must have their own states (charged or uncharged)
What do you mean by this? Regardless of what you mean here, oscillatory motion of subatomic particles or a boundstate of them is by far only possible when driven by electric field, and that requires the driven object to be charged.Silicon Waffle said:transferred back and forth in their environments.
I didn't write much as this is a basic but tricky known question. And I would like to make it brief in a general sense. It is not called an atom anymore once after it is charged.blue_leaf77 said:An atom stripped out all of their electrons is called an ion and it's charged. No ions is uncharged.
With regards to what I mentioned, I would have added more to explain reactions like thisWhat do you mean by this? Regardless of what you mean here, oscillatory motion of subatomic particles or a boundstate of them is by far only possible when driven by electric field, and that requires the driven object to be charged.
I still can't grasp what you intended to mean here. Is it because you are accustomed to calling bare ion an atom or you really wanted to mean something fancy?Silicon Waffle said:A neutral hydrogen atom is produced after the cation is reacted with hydrogen gas, which means electron-less atoms exist.
Actually this isn't quite true for the reaction you've given. A proton never exists "on it's own" in water, or any aqueous acid - the proton is always solvated by one or more unionized water molecules: ##H_3 O^+ (H_2 O)_n##Silicon Waffle said:which means electron-less atoms exist.