Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the feasibility of enclosing a relatively high electric charge within a non-conducting container, specifically focusing on the technical aspects of maintaining a net charge and the implications for external electric fields. Participants explore theoretical and practical considerations related to electrostatics, insulator properties, and charge stability.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant questions whether it is technically possible to enclose a charge greater than 10e-5 coulombs in a non-conducting material like glass or plastic.
- Another participant clarifies that they are referring to a charge in the center of a sphere, emphasizing that the overall charge of the object would not be zero.
- A participant raises concerns about the stability of such a charge configuration, mentioning the breakdown field of the insulator and potential neutralization effects from external factors like cosmic rays.
- There is a discussion about the mechanical strength of the insulator against Coulomb repulsion, with a warning about the possibility of a Coulomb explosion if the charge becomes too concentrated.
- Further inquiries are made regarding the ability of a glass sphere to withstand a high electric field and whether other insulators with higher breakdown fields exist.
- Participants discuss the implications of creating a spherical capacitor with charges on its inner and outer surfaces, questioning whether it can maintain its charge over an extended period and generate a net electric field outside.
- One participant expresses interest in achieving significant attractive or repulsive forces between objects, comparing the complexity of magnetic and electric force calculations.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express various viewpoints on the feasibility and implications of enclosing electric charge, with no consensus reached on the technical limits or configurations that would allow for stable charge retention and external interactions.
Contextual Notes
Participants note limitations related to the breakdown fields of materials, the effects of environmental factors on charge stability, and the mechanical constraints of the insulator material. The discussion does not resolve these complexities.