Can you get pulled under a train?

  • Thread starter Thread starter dextercioby
  • Start date Start date
Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
36 replies · 7K views
.Scott said:
That last statement does not apply to US Navy carriers - since they can only be supplied this way on their starboard side.
But what if one of the carriers is running in reverse? Then two right sides are available.
 
Reply
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: sophiecentaur
Physics news on Phys.org
jbriggs444 said:
But what if one of the carriers is running in reverse? Then two right sides are available.
Very difficult to reverse a straight line. The driver has to lean too far out of the bridge window to see behind him.
1763071315987.webp


Plus, the prop walk is brutal.
 
Last edited:
DaveC426913 said:
The driver has to lean too far out of the bridge window to see behind him.
All the Captain can do is to try to keep a steady course; he can't see a thing from the bridge. It's up to the Pilot boat helm to chase the boarding ladder. I imagine they have radio communication so the captain can stop (or start) worrying after the event.

PS Is it possible that Naval craft use commercial pilots? I guess they have no option in non-naval ports (Left hand down a bit)
 
sophiecentaur said:
PS Is it possible that Naval craft use commercial pilots? I guess they have no option in non-naval ports (Left hand down a bit)

Decades ago, I worked with a Navy veteran with experience in this area. He reported a story about a particular instance of using a Maritime pilot - and his mention suggested that this was typical.

Of course, the Navy would not always opt for the services of a local pilot. The approach to the beach at Playa Girón, Cuba comes to mind as an example.
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: sophiecentaur
dextercioby said:
Kurz gesagt: Ein praktisches Problem beim Aufenthalt in der Nähe von Bahngleisen. Kann/Sollte man das tun? Was wäre, wenn der Zug in Hanoi 100 km/h fahren würde?

Angenommen, ein 100 m langer (wahrscheinlich irrelevanter) Zug mit einer Geschwindigkeit von 30 m/s und einer Masse von 100.000 kg fährt an einer 100 kg schweren Person vorbei, die 1 m von den Gleisen entfernt steht. Da der Zug die Luft massiv verdrängt und so ein kleines Vakuum bzw. einen Unterdruckbereich erzeugt, übt er vermutlich eine Anziehungskraft auf alles aus, woran er vorbeifährt – in diesem Fall also auf eine Person. Meine Frage ist ganz einfach: Lässt sich diese Anziehungskraft durch eine Kraft quantifizieren? Reicht diese Kraft aus, um die Person unter den Zug zu ziehen? Was wäre, wenn der Abstand 50 cm betrüge?
First there is a pressure surge, then a weaker suction at the end. Only if you are standing very unsteadily could this cause you to fall over.
In Austria, a stroller once rolled under a train. The slight jolt was enough to set it rolling. Since then, there have been straps on the platform to secure strollers.