Can You Get Shocked Without Being Grounded?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gruxg
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the concept of electrical shock and grounding, highlighting that a person can receive a shock even without direct grounding due to capacitive effects. It emphasizes that touching a live wire can result in current flow through the body, particularly if the individual is isolated from the ground, as demonstrated by the use of a high-resistance tester. The conversation also touches on the behavior of large objects, like the human body, in relation to AC generators and the potential for current flow despite an open circuit. Additionally, it clarifies that birds can safely land on power lines because they do not create a path to ground. Ultimately, the discussion concludes that a person touching a live wire can indeed be shocked, with current flowing through their body to an unspecified grounding point.
Gruxg
Messages
43
Reaction score
2
It is ussually thought that if you receive a shock touching only one cable is because you are not well isolated from ground. In theory, if you touch only one wire in one point and you are not conected to ground, you should not get a discharge (we all have seen small birds in the transmission lines). However, I have noticed that if I am standing on a plastic stool and not touching the ground anywere and I touch a live wire with one of those test lights like a screwdriver used by the electricians, it indicates current. This tester is only a light and a very high resistance between the wire and my finger, and it is indicating that the current is going into my body (with small intensity due to the high resistance of the tester). I guess my body is acting like a capacitor or something like that. It is possible to receive a painful or dangerous shock if you are not grounded, only by the capacitive effect?.

And in a more general sense, if an large object (like a human body) is conected to one of the terminals of an AC generator but the circuit is open (no return cable) and there are no other objects close to the big body that can act as "the other plate of the capacitor", can there still be a current?. If the body is sufficient large, I do not find any physical reasons to think that this would not happen. However it breaks a bit with the common asumptions of the circuit theory.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org


 
Last edited by a moderator:


skeptic2 said:

Note the guy in that video is wearing a "faraday cage" like suit. Since the guy on the wire provides an additional parallel path to the current flowing through the wire, a small percentage of current would flow through the guy if not for the "faraday cage" suit that carries that small percentage of current instead.
 
Last edited by a moderator:


No it doesn't break with circuit theory.
A human is usually modeled as having a capacitance relative to Earth and a resistance.
So yes, if you touch an ac line there is a always a current flowing. That's also the reason why birds never land on high voltage power lines. They may land on medium voltage lines or on the ground wire of a high voltage power line. But never on wires carrying more than a few dozen kV.
 


Just curious, let's say that someone hypothetically climbs a utility pole with no special equipment/clothing on and grabs a live wire. Will they get shocked? And if so, where is the current going through them grounding to?
 


spamctor said:
Just curious, let's say that someone hypothetically climbs a utility pole with no special equipment/clothing on and grabs a live wire. Will they get shocked? And if so, where is the current going through them grounding to?
Consider the person to be similar to an antenna connected to an 500,000 to 700,000 volt AC power source, there is current flowing through an "antenna" as the AC voltage at the powered end of the "antenna" cycles back and forth.
 
Last edited:
I was using the Smith chart to determine the input impedance of a transmission line that has a reflection from the load. One can do this if one knows the characteristic impedance Zo, the degree of mismatch of the load ZL and the length of the transmission line in wavelengths. However, my question is: Consider the input impedance of a wave which appears back at the source after reflection from the load and has traveled for some fraction of a wavelength. The impedance of this wave as it...
Back
Top