Characterizing random processes

Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around identifying and characterizing various random processes as part of a statistics course. The user presents their attempts at classifying different scenarios, primarily focusing on Poisson and related distributions, while seeking clarification on parameters and properties. Key points include the identification of the rain gauge output as a Poisson random variable and the confusion surrounding the parameters for certain distributions, such as the Bernoulli and Geometric distributions. Participants agree on some classifications but express uncertainty about others, particularly regarding the negative binomial and binomial distributions. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the need for guidance in understanding the relationships and specifications of random variables in statistical contexts.
ashah99
Messages
55
Reaction score
2
Homework Statement
Please see below.
Relevant Equations
Distribution parameters
Hello. I would like to kindly request some help with a multi-part problem on identifying random processes as an intro topic from my stats course. I’m fairly uncertain with this topic so I suspect my attempt is mostly incorrect, especially when specifying the parameters, and I would be grateful for any guidance and help with understanding this better.

The problem statement:

rv_prob.jpg


My attempt:
a) Poisson( ##\lambda ## = 3)

b) Poisson( ##\lambda ## = 9), where ## X_1, X_2, X_3 ## are all ~Poisson(3), and I believe a property of Poission RVs is that a sum is also Poisson with ##\lambda ## = ##\lambda_1 + \lambda_2 + \lambda_3##

Sum of iid Bernoulli RVs is binomial

c) Bernoulli(##e^{-1}##)

d) Geometric(p=1/2), not sure on the parameter
Waiting times between successive flashes are iid geo RVs where the rate is 1 per sec

e) Exp(3) Since the rate is 3 arrivals/sec

f) NegBinomial(p=1/2, k=3) not sure on the parameter
waiting time for k-th arrival, where k = 3

g) Binomial(n = 10, p = 1/2) not sure on the parameter

h) Erlang(##\lambda ## = 3, k = 3) not sure on the parameter
Waiting time for continuous Poisson process where lambda is the arrival rate and k=3
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
The problem statement is not visible. It's just a jpeg file name.
 
FactChecker said:
The problem statement is not visible. It's just a jpeg file name.
Interesting, I edited my posted, hope it shows up
 
FactChecker said:
The problem statement is not visible. It's just a jpeg file name.

ashah99 said:
Interesting, I edited my posted, hope it shows up
It shows up now.
 
  • Like
Likes FactChecker and ashah99
I’m quite thrown off with how the rain gauge outputting a random sequence at a rate of one every second comes into play in this problem, especially when specifying the partners for the RVs.
 
ashah99 said:
I’m quite thrown off with how the rain gauge outputting a random sequence at a rate of one every second comes into play in this problem,
The output of the rain gauge is the Poisson RV. The number of raindrops hitting the rain gauge in one second has the Poisson distribution, Pois(3). It is related to a lot of other distributions.
ashah99 said:
especially when specifying the partners for the RVs.
I don't know what "partners" means. Are you talking about the related distributions like exponential, etc. ?
 
Last edited:
FactChecker said:
The output of the rain gauge is the Poisson RV. The number of raindrops hitting the rain gauge in one second has the Poisson distribution, Pois(3). It is related to a lot of other distributions.

I don't know what "partners" means. Are you talking about the related distributions like exponential, etc. ?
Sorry, I meant parameters (i.e. the lambda in Poisson(3) ). I'm quite sure of my answers for parts a and b but the rest is making me confused. Would you be willing to check and guide through mistakes?
 
ashah99 said:
My attempt:
a) Poisson( ##\lambda ## = 3)
Agree
ashah99 said:
b) Poisson( ##\lambda ## = 9), where ## X_1, X_2, X_3 ## are all ~Poisson(3), and I believe a property of Poission RVs is that a sum is also Poisson with ##\lambda ## = ##\lambda_1 + \lambda_2 + \lambda_3##
Agree
ashah99 said:
Sum of iid Bernoulli RVs is binomial

c) Bernoulli(##e^{-1}##)
Shouldn't the parameter be ##Pois(X=0, \lambda = 3) = \lambda^0 e^{-\lambda}/0!##
ashah99 said:
d) Geometric(p=1/2), not sure on the parameter
Waiting times between successive flashes are iid geo RVs where the rate is 1 per sec
This seems like a negative binomial to me.
ashah99 said:
e) Exp(3) Since the rate is 3 arrivals/sec
Agree

I'm not expert enough to help on the rest.
ashah99 said:
f) NegBinomial(p=1/2, k=3) not sure on the parameter
waiting time for k-th arrival, where k = 3

g) Binomial(n = 10, p = 1/2) not sure on the parameter

h) Erlang(##\lambda ## = 3, k = 3) not sure on the parameter
Waiting time for continuous Poisson process where lambda is the arrival rate and k=3
 
FactChecker said:
Agree

Agree

Shouldn't the parameter be ##Pois(X=0, \lambda = 3) = \lambda^0 e^{-\lambda}/0!##

This seems like a negative binomial to me.

Agree

I'm not expert enough to help on the rest.
For part (c) I think you are right, I think I mixed it up with the one output per second output from the rain gauge. So, I believe the final answer should be ##Bernoulli(e^{-3})##.

So, for part (d), you think it is NegBin, but I'm not not sure what the p and k parameters should be (see notes below)?

So, for the rest of the parts, I used these notes of discrete vs. continuous Poisson that I found online, so my latter answers are based off those:
1670769931569.png