Comparing 2 Fraction based variables

  • Thread starter zak100
  • Start date
  • #1
462
11

Homework Statement


c & d are positive integers &
1/c = 1 + 1/d
Now tell which is greater c or d?

Homework Equations


1/c = 1 + 1/d

The Attempt at a Solution


1/c = (d+1)/d

c = d/ (d+1)
c = 1 + d

Thus if c =10
therefore d = 9
But this is not a correct answer. Some body please guide me.

Zulfi.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Nidum
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2,990
848
Hint : Which is smaller 1/c or 1/d ?
 
  • #3
176
19
You could also just sub in values and make inferences from that
 
  • #4
Charles Link
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2020 Award
4,860
2,187
For c, d positive integers, 1/c is always less than 1 unless c=1. I think the statement of the problem is incorrect that c and d are positive integers. There is no solution. c=1 implies d=+infinity. If the problem statement had said positive reals, then in one case c<1 and d>1. In another case, c<1 and d<1 and c<d, so that c<d if c, d are positive reals.
 
Last edited:
  • #5
Ray Vickson
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Dearly Missed
10,706
1,728

Homework Statement


c & d are positive integers &
1/c = 1 + 1/d
Now tell which is greater c or d?

Homework Equations


1/c = 1 + 1/d

The Attempt at a Solution


1/c = (d+1)/d

c = d/ (d+1)
c = 1 + d

Thus if c =10
therefore d = 9
But this is not a correct answer. Some body please guide me.

Zulfi.
As pointed out in #4, the equation is impossible if c and d are positive integers; however, if they are just positive real numbers, then the equation says that 1/c is a bigger number than 1/d. What does that say about c and d themselves?
 
  • Like
Likes Charles Link
  • #6
462
11
Hi,
Thanks for your help. Actually it says that " c & d are positive".

<Which is smaller 1/c or 1/d ?>
I think it depends on values. They can be equal.

<
In another case, c<1 and d<1 and c<d, so that c<d if c, d are positive reals.>
If c & d are positive reals this means that c & d can be integers also.
What's wrong with my solution. I have proved that c is greater. However the answer says that d is greater.

Zulfi.
 
  • #7
Charles Link
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2020 Award
4,860
2,187
Hi,
Thanks for your help. Actually it says that " c & d are positive".

<Which is smaller 1/c or 1/d ?>
I think it depends on values. They can be equal.

<
In another case, c<1 and d<1 and c<d, so that c<d if c, d are positive reals.>
If c & d are positive reals this means that c & d can be integers also.
What's wrong with my solution. I have proved that c is greater. However the answer says that d is greater.

Zulfi.
Your last line of post #1 c=1+d is incorrect. Meanwhile, since 1/c=1+1/d, this says the right side of the equation is greater than 1. That means c must be less than 1 (to make the left side greater than 1) and therefore c can not be a positive integer.
 
  • #8
Nidum
Science Advisor
Gold Member
2,990
848
I guessed that the use of integer was a typo - the question did not make sense otherwise .

Now think about this :

If x is greater than y then is 1/x greater or less than 1/y ? Put some numbers in if it helps - say 10 for x and 5 for y .
 
  • #9
462
11
Hi,
Thanks for your response. I got my mistake. I am now able to understand book's solution.
According to the book,
c = d/ (d+1)
Since d is positive, so d+1> d. if d= 7 then 7/(7+1) (which is a fraction & less than d). So d > d/(d+1). But c=d/(d+1). So d>c.

Now your question:
"If x is greater than y then is 1/x greater or less than 1/y ? Put some numbers in if it helps - say 10 for x and 5 for y" .

i.e. x> y so 1/x < 1/y. Inequalities reverse. 10> 5 so 1/10 < 1/5.

Thanks for help.

Zulfi.
 
  • #11
34,667
6,379
Hi,
I have a question with my original solution:
i.e
1/c = 1 + 1/d
Why cant we write:
c= 1 + d?
Because it is incorrect. See below.
zak100 said:
which is obtained by taking reciprocal of both sides.
The reciprocal of ##1 + \frac 1 d## is NOT 1 + d.
Here is an example using numbers.
$$\frac 1 {\frac 1 3} = 1 + \frac 1 {\frac 1 2}$$
Does it follow that ##\frac 1 3 = 1 + \frac 1 2##?


zak100 said:
 

Related Threads on Comparing 2 Fraction based variables

Replies
2
Views
7K
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
897
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
7K
  • Last Post
Replies
9
Views
671
Replies
1
Views
2K
Top