Karimspencer
- 117
- 0
do you consider Covalent radius, Van der Waals radius or atomic radius?
The discussion revolves around the concept of atomic volume and the appropriate radius to consider when estimating it. Participants explore different types of radii, including covalent radius, Van der Waals radius, and atomic radius, and the implications of these choices for calculations and estimations.
Participants do not reach a consensus on how to define or calculate atomic volume, with multiple competing views on the appropriate radius to use and the nature of atomic volume itself.
There are limitations regarding the definitions and contexts of the various radii discussed, as well as the assumptions underlying their use in calculations.
I said nothing even remotely suggesting this. There is no "right" way to "find" the volume of an atom, because it does not have one. Even if there was a right way, just averaging random unrelated quantities without any reason to so would most certainly not be it.Karimspencer said:oh ok, so do you think the right way to find the volume of the atom is to find the average of the covalent radius, vdw radius and atomic radius?