Could a Magnetic Car Revolutionize Transportation?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
Sign up Log in
8 replies · 7K views
AussieDave
Messages
47
Reaction score
0
Hey guys. My mate, who is from a non-physics background, proposed the idea of a magnetic car to me. I'm currently doing high-school physics but have not yet covered magnetism. My basic question is, would this in fact work? Maybe he stumbled across something quite clever or maybe it'd just plain suck hehehe. Here is a pic of his drawing :p

http://i110.photobucket.com/albums/n101/FirstPanzerDiv/Self-PropelledCar.jpg
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What direction is the car supposed to move in? (this is an important point)
 
AussieDave said:
Maybe he stumbled across something quite clever or maybe it'd just plain suck hehehe. [/url]

My initial vote is -b-, because it looks like a perpetual motion idea.
 
How is this thing supposed to move, exactly?
 
I understand your mate's idea, that must involve the smart-breaking-system: front wheels break and stop, then let magnet attract to increase the beam tension and store the energy on the beam or even springs, then break the back wheels and then release the front wheels - let the beam or springs (with stored energy) to push the front wheels, very very clever perpetual system, he is using the free,cheap and clean magnetic powers! But I think the energies used to break the wheels will also be very great, maybe used at the same rate as the magnetic power used? I don't know. Could be or could be not, if not, then this system is the solution to new energy! Great!@

Also, remind you that the magnetic energy will be used up sooner or later in this sytem.

We could manufacture this kind of spring engine! Why not.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, rethinking it again, I was wrong, because when the magnets are closer, that means the attraction force is getting much greater, the beam or springs need much more energy to fight off the magnetic power, they cancel each others out, that means no more or very little energy left to drive the car, also consider the energy is needed to break the wheels, it will become a waste of power, LOL. Sigh, no energy comes free.
 
Looks to me like either one pole repelling a like one ahead of itself, or one attracting an opposite one behind itself. Either way, it's not going anywhere. If one of those magnets was mounted off of the vehicle, however, the idea would work (as in maglev trains).
 
Thanks guys. I wouldn't read too much into his thoughts behind it. Basically, what you see in the diagram is what you get. I was thinking along the lines of Electron with "How is this thing supposed to move, exactly?"