Detection of a Quantum Measurement

In summary, if it is known that a photon has diagonal polarisation and Alice measures it using a horizontal/vertical polarisation basis, there is a 50% chance she will get a horizontal result and a 50% chance for a vertical result. Bob can perform an experiment to check if the particle's polarisation has been measured, but generally there is no way for him to know.
  • #1
chrisphd
60
0
Suppose it is known that a photon has diagonal polarisation (e.g. it has just passed through a diagonal slit), then Alice comes along and measures the photon using a horizontal/vertical polarisation basis. So, I believe there is a 50% chance she will get a horizontal result and 50% chance she will obtain a vertical result.

Now Bob comes along and also knows the particle has passed through the diagonal slit, but he is unaware that Alice has already made a measurement using a horizontal/vertical basis. Is there an experiment Bob can do to check if the particle's polarisation has been measured?

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
chrisphd said:
Suppose it is known that a photon has diagonal polarisation (e.g. it has just passed through a diagonal slit), then Alice comes along and measures the photon using a horizontal/vertical polarisation basis. So, I believe there is a 50% chance she will get a horizontal result and 50% chance she will obtain a vertical result.

Now Bob comes along and also knows the particle has passed through the diagonal slit, but he is unaware that Alice has already made a measurement using a horizontal/vertical basis. Is there an experiment Bob can do to check if the particle's polarisation has been measured?

Thanks

No in this case, and also generally no.
 
  • #3
Hello.

DrChinese said:
No in this case, and also generally no.

Measurement of Alice decreases percentage of Bob's finding diagonal polarized photon to 50%, doesn't it?
 

1. What is a quantum measurement?

A quantum measurement is the process of obtaining information about a quantum system, such as its position or momentum. This measurement causes the quantum system to collapse into a definite state.

2. How is a quantum measurement different from a classical measurement?

In a classical measurement, the system being measured is not affected by the act of measurement. However, in a quantum measurement, the act of measurement causes the system to collapse into a definite state, making it impossible to know its previous state.

3. How is a quantum measurement detected?

There are several methods for detecting a quantum measurement, including using a photon detector, detecting changes in the energy level of an atom, or observing changes in the spin of an electron.

4. Why is the detection of a quantum measurement important?

The detection of a quantum measurement is important because it allows us to understand and manipulate quantum systems, which can lead to advancements in fields such as computing, communication, and cryptography.

5. What are some challenges in detecting a quantum measurement?

One of the main challenges in detecting a quantum measurement is the delicate nature of quantum systems, which can be easily disturbed by external factors. Additionally, the act of measurement itself can alter the state of the system, making it difficult to obtain accurate results.

Similar threads

Replies
99
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
743
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
4
Views
634
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
713
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
8
Views
913
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
5
Views
724
  • Quantum Physics
Replies
13
Views
623
Replies
28
Views
536
Replies
7
Views
1K
Back
Top