# I Difference between global and local gauge symmetries

Tags:
1. Feb 11, 2017

### Frank Castle

The mantra in theoretical physics is that global gauge transformations are physical symmetries of a theory, whereas local gauge transformations are simply redundancies (representing redundant degrees of freedom (dof)) of a theory.

My question is, what distinguishes them (other than being global and local - independent and dependent on spacetime coordinates)? In particular, why is one (global gauge symmetry) considered to be a physical symmetry with an associated Noether current, whereas the other (local gauge symmetry) is not?

For example, the archetypal gauge theory is classical electromagnetism: under a local gauge transformation the 4-potential $A^{\mu}(x)$ transforms as $$A^{\mu}(x)\rightarrow A'^{\mu}(x)=A^{\mu}(x)+\partial^{\mu}\Lambda(x)$$ This, however, leaves the physically measurable field strength $F^{\mu\nu}(x)$ unchanged, i.e. $$F^{\mu\nu}(x)\rightarrow F'^{\mu\nu}(x)=F^{\mu\nu}(x)$$ As I understand it, this is what is meant by a local gauge symmetry being a redundancy in the description of the physical theory, since it simply reflects the fact that the physically unmeasurable quantities used to describe the theory, in this case $A^{\mu}$, are not uniquely defined. They are introduced as a convenience to describe the theory, and their non-uniqueness is a relic of how we use them to represent physical quantities, and not due to some physical symmetry of the system. (Another example would be in GR - coordinates are introduced to describe physical quantities locally (i.e. project a tensor onto a particular coordinate basis), however, such coordinates are not uniquely defined, one can choose any set of admissable coordinates to describe the same physical quantity).

When it comes to a global symmetry, however, I'm not sure at all how to argue why this is a physical symmetry as opposed to simply a redundancy in the description of the physical theory?!

2. Feb 14, 2017

### Frank Castle

Anyone got any thoughts on this? Any help would be much appreciated!