Difference calculating enthalpy change by using thermodynamic table A-17 vs. A-2 with integration

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
lost captain
Messages
89
Reaction score
7
Let's say i want to find the change in enthalpy of air from 400K to 800K.
The most accurate way is to use the table A-17.(see picture)
"Find the table that has the enthalpy changes from a random reference temperature to find the enthalpy change as the difference between enthalpies."

Now the second option and less accurate than the 1st one, is using table A-2
"Find the polynomial coefficients and carry out the integral."

My question is why these two results aren't the same? The first is 420.97 kJ/kg and the second comes out as 422.66 kJ/kg .
In the second option, If I'm integrating then I'm taking into account that cp changes with temperature, so shouldn't this value be found both by the second method and the first?
Obviously that doesn't happen, so that leaves me wondering how are the values in table A-17 calculated? I falsely thought that they came from integration from the diagram cp-Temperature.


This question came to me after watching this video:
The pictures are also screenshot from that video.

Thanks in advance for anyone taking the time answering🙇‍♂️😌
 
Attachments
  • Excerpt of Table A-17, ideal-gas properties of air, listing temperature T in K, enthalpy h in kJ/kg, relative pressure Pr, internal energy u in kJ/kg, relative volume vr and entropy s° in kJ/kg·K for 200 K to 880 K.
    Notes_260307_093708_e0e.webp
    54.1 KB · Views: 37
  • Table A-2 (concluded) of ideal-gas specific heats: polynomial coefficients a, b, c, d for cp as a function of temperature for nitrogen, oxygen, air and hydrogen, with temperature range 273-1800 K and percent error.
    Notes_260307_093733_623.webp
    21 KB · Views: 33
  • Handwritten derivation: polynomial fit for cp-bar = a + bT + cT^2 + dT^3 integrated from 400 K to 800 K, giving delta-h-bar = 12244.443 kJ/kmol and delta-h = 422.66 kJ/kg using M = 28.97 kg/kmol.
    Notes_260307_093736_d53.webp
    33.6 KB · Views: 27
  • Hand-drawn graph of molar specific heat cp in kJ/(kmol·K) against temperature T in K, showing curves for CO2, H2O, O2, H2 and Air, with a linear cp average segment between cp1 and cp2.
    Notes_260307_101534_0df.webp
    23.9 KB · Views: 33
The table in the first method used integration with respect to temperature also. It would seem to be a matter of the difference in the accuracy of the two fits of Cp. vs T.