Differentiate 1/√(1+x²) from first principles without getting stuck

  • Context: Undergrad 
  • Thread starter Thread starter rsnd
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Limit
Join the discussion
Registration is free. Ask a follow-up in this thread, or start your own.
5 replies · 2K views
rsnd
Messages
26
Reaction score
0
I was told to differentiate by definition! Function
f = 1/(sqrt(1+x^2));

which gives me the expression
Lim(h->0) {(1/(sqrt(1+(x+h)^2)) - 1/(sqrt(1+x^2)))/h}
problem is...I can’t seem to get rid of the h at the bottom...I’ve tried all the math packages I have including maple and all of them just seem to complicate things! what should be the simplified version of that function so I don’t get h at the bottom resulting in undefined numbers. or is there a different way to look at this definition problem?

Thanks heaps
K. Civilian
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why would you want to get rid of it? you need to let it tend to zero...


This ought to help:


Edit:


sqrt(a)-sqrt(b)= (a-b)/(sqrt(a)+sqrt(b))
 
Last edited:
I suggest you start like this :

( 1 + (x+h)^2 )^(-1/2)

= ( 1 + x^2 + (2x+h)h )^(-1/2)

= (1 + x^2)^(-1/2) ( 1 + (2x+h)/(1+x^2) h )^(-1/2)

Then do a binomial expansion of the "(1 + (2x+h)/(1+x^2) h)^(-1/2)" factor and it's pretty straight forward from there.
 
matt grime said:
Why would you want to get rid of it? you need to let it tend to zero...
Because if it is in the denominator as it goes to 0 it will cause a lot of trouble!


This ought to help:

sqrt(a)-sqrt(b)= 1/(sqrt(a)+sqrt(b))

Provided a-b= 1?
 
Noted my mistake.

But the point is that if you use that corrected identity, then you get something where the h on bottom cancels off, and you just have an h on top, let it go to zero and the correct derivative drops out.

Since it's easier to typeset, here's the idea of 1/x

1/(x+h) - 1/x = -h/(x+h)(x)

divide through by h and now let he tend to zero to see that the derivative is -1/x^2

that works here too, but it's a bugger to typeset.
 
Last edited:
matt grime said:
Noted my mistake.

But the point is that if you use that corrected identity, then you get something where the h on bottom cancels off, and you just have an h on top, let it go to zero and the correct derivative drops out.QUOTE]

Yes, but I assumed that was what the orginal post meant by "get rid of the h at the bottom".