Does ice do work when it melts or freezes?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Saippo
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Ice Work
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on whether ice performs work during melting and freezing processes. When water freezes, it expands, indicating that work is done as it pushes against atmospheric pressure. Conversely, when ice melts, the volume does not change significantly, leading to confusion about whether work is involved. However, it is clarified that while the melting process involves energy, the work done is primarily related to the change in volume during freezing. Overall, the conversation highlights the complexities of work in thermodynamic processes involving ice and water.
Saippo
Messages
10
Reaction score
1
Since when you freeze liquid water, there's an expansion, wouldn't that mean there's work?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
What's the definition of work?
 
delta W = pAs = pV so a change of volume would indicate a change of work wouldn't it?
 
Yep ice does work when expanding.
It pushes some atmosphere away...
A thought like that turns up in the definition of enthalpy.

A little disclaimer: The energies in this(only for ice not other enthalpy stuff) are absolutely pathetico0).
 
Saippo said:
delta W = pAs = pV so a change of volume would indicate a change of work wouldn't it?
Right. In this way, work is dependent on volume. So ice does work when it's expanding. Work is simply the energy required to do something--and the ice is obviously using energy to melt. Actually, it's increasing in energy as it melts.

EDIT: Oh, Tazerfish beat me to it.
 
I guess what sort of made me wonder about it is when ice melts, the volume doesn't actually change..right? So no work. But if you freeze liquid water, ice expands. So work done?
 
Ice doesn't change the volume when melting ?:confused:
Of course it does.
So the outside does work on the ice.
 
Saippo said:
I guess what sort of made me wonder about it is when ice melts, the volume doesn't actually change..right? So no work. But if you freeze liquid water, ice expands. So work done?
Water has a lesser volume than ice.
 
  • #10
Ooh alright! I was reading a line in my textbook completely wrong. Ah that was dumb Thanks!
 
  • #11
ProfuselyQuarky said:
Right. In this way, work is dependent on volume. So ice does work when it's expanding. Work is simply the energy required to do something--and the ice is obviously using energy to melt. Actually, it's increasing in energy as it melts.

EDIT: Oh, Tazerfish beat me to it.
Not only did he beat you to it, but his answer is correct, and yours isn't. Most of the energy involved in melting has nothing to do with the work done by atmospheric pressure. Also, ice receives work from the atmosphere in contracting; it doesn't expand when it melts.
 
  • Like
Likes SammyS and ProfuselyQuarky
  • #12
Chestermiller said:
Not only did he beat you to it, but his answer is correct, and yours isn't. Most of the energy involved in melting has nothing to do with the work done by atmospheric pressure. Also, ice receives work from the atmosphere in contracting; it doesn't expand when it melts.
I wasn't talking about pressure. I was talking about volume. And I never said ice expands when it melts.
 
  • #13
ProfuselyQuarky said:
I wasn't talking about pressure. I was talking about volume. And I never said ice expands when it melts.
Work is equal to ##\int{P_{ext}}dV##, where, in this case, ##P_{ext}## is atmospheric pressure. So a change in volume in melting ice is accompanied by work being done. This is a small part of the heat of melting.
 
  • #14
Tazerfish said:
A little disclaimer: The energies in this(only for ice not other enthalpy stuff) are absolutely pathetico0).

It is still able to burst pipes and cause plumbers headaches though :-p
 
  • Like
Likes Tazerfish
Back
Top