Does mixing glycerol into water effect electrolysis of water?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the effects of mixing glycerol into water on the electrolysis of water. Participants explore the changes in electrical resistance, potential oxidation of glycerol, and the implications for conductivity and chemical reactions during electrolysis.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested
  • Mathematical reasoning

Main Points Raised

  • One participant measured the resistance of deionized (DI) water and found it to decrease after mixing with glycerol, suggesting a change in conductivity.
  • Another participant noted that organic compounds like glycerol can be oxidized at the anode during electrolysis, potentially forming various oxidation products.
  • Questions were raised about the specific water-to-glycerol ratio used in experiments and its impact on conductivity.
  • Concerns were expressed regarding the conductivity of glycerol-water mixtures and the accuracy of referenced conductivity values.
  • Some participants discussed the role of ions in conductivity, questioning whether glycerol introduces any ions into the solution.
  • There was a debate about whether non-ionic compounds can undergo oxidation during electrolysis if a conductive medium is present.
  • One participant suggested that the movement of ions in the solution could affect other compounds, prompting further inquiry into the mechanisms at play.
  • Another participant mentioned that glycerol is miscible in water but questioned whether it dissociates in solution.
  • Discussion included the relative acidity of glycerol compared to water and its potential effects on dissociation and conductivity.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants do not reach a consensus on whether glycerol changes into new compounds during electrolysis, the extent of its dissociation, or the implications for conductivity. Multiple competing views remain regarding the chemical behavior of glycerol in electrolysis.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include uncertainties about the specific chemical reactions occurring during electrolysis, the exact role of glycerol in conductivity, and the accuracy of referenced conductivity data.

kevin_tee
Messages
80
Reaction score
2
Does mixing glycerol into water effect electrolysis of water?
I tried measuring ohm and the resistance of water is lower after mixing glycerol.
Then I experiment electrolysis of water, first I measure the resistance of DI water and it turns out that the resistant is about 0.63 mega ohm.
Then mix DI water and glycerol and the resistant went down to 0.6 mega ohm.
I mix sodium sulfate and glycerol into water to decrease the resistant then suddenly the gas is produce.
The gas that is produce seems to be 2:1 ratio (hydrogen:oxygen) but I can't analyse the gas so I'm not sure if the gas that is produce is hydrogen and oxygen or not.
Does glycerol change into new compound due to electrolysis? Thanks.:biggrin:
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
kevin_tee said:
Does glycerol change into new compound due to electrolysis? Thanks.:biggrin:

Organic compounds in solution can be oxidized at the anode in electrolysis. Oxidation products of glycerol could be things like dihydroxyacetone or tartronic acid, or the oxidation could proceed all the way to water and carbon dioxide.
 
kevin_tee said:
first I measure the resistance of DI water and it turns out that the resistant is about 0.63 mega ohm.
Then mix DI water and glycerol and the resistant went down to 0.6 mega ohm.

What water/glycerol ratio?

What is responsible for the conductivity of water solutions?
 
The water is 80 ml and glycerol is 5 ml. The electrode that used to measure the resistant of water is place roughly (but keeping the same distance)just to know that the resistivity change or not.
The conductivity of DI water could be the contaminant of the beaker, the conductivity of water is ion, an ion carry electrical charge + and -, the cation is discharge at the anode and anion is discharge at the cathode.
 
Thanks for the information hilbert2.
I have research a little bit and it seems that glycerol doesn't change into other chemical since it is not ionic compound (it is polyol) so it doesn't carry electric charge. Am I correct? Correct me if I am wrong.Thanks.
 
Last edited:
hilbert2 said:
Organic compounds in solution can be oxidized at the anode in electrolysis. Oxidation products of glycerol could be things like dihydroxyacetone or tartronic acid, or the oxidation could proceed all the way to water and carbon dioxide.
So any compound that conduct electricity does form new compound due to electrolysis?
 
Even non-ionic compounds can often be oxidized electrolytically. One just has to add in the solution some other compound that makes it conductive. For example, if you electrolyze a solution of sodium chloride in water-ethanol mixture (using platinum electrodes), you will soon find that the resulting solution contains several oxidation and chlorination products of ethanol, such as acetic acid, chloral hydrate and trichloroacetic acid.
 
Thanks for the answer, but why does it do that? Can't the electrolyte just ignore other compound and conduct electricity normally without oxidizing-reducing other compound? I though the conductivity of electrolyte is the movement of ion. How does movement of ion effect other compound?
 
  • #10
hilbert2 said:
The electrical conductivities of glycerol-water mixtures can be found here on page 23: http://www.aciscience.org/docs/physical_properties_of_glycerine_and_its_solutions.pdf .

There is a slight problem with the table - it assumes conductivity of pure water to be around 107 MΩ (that is assuming I read the exponent correctly), while it should be around 1.8×107 MΩ.

That's not to say it is completely wrong, but it is obviously a bit off.
 
  • #11
kevin_tee said:
the conductivity of water is ion, an ion carry electrical charge + and -, the cation is discharge at the anode and anion is discharge at the cathode.

Good.

Do you introduce any ions into the solution by adding glycerol?
 
  • #12
kevin_tee said:
Thanks for the answer, but why does it do that? Can't the electrolyte just ignore other compound and conduct electricity normally without oxidizing-reducing other compound? I though the conductivity of electrolyte is the movement of ion. How does movement of ion effect other compound?

It is not about what is happening in the bulk of the solution, where the ions are mostly migrating as inert charge carriers. But the charge has to somehow pass the phase boundary (solution/electrode), and that's where the reactions take place.
 
  • #13
Borek said:
Good.

Do you introduce any ions into the solution by adding glycerol?

I have research a little and I found out that glycerol is miscible in water, so it does not introduce any ion, am I right?
 
  • #14
Miscibility doesn't matter, dissociation does. Does the glycerol dissociate?
 
  • #15
Alcohols should dissociate, slightly.
For example, ethanol is almost as strong acid as water - in aqueous solution.
The reactions
HOH=H++OH-
and
C2H5OH=H++C2H5O-
have very similar equilibrium constants - pKa is 15,7 for water and 16 for ethanol. If you dissolve alkali in ethanol, the reaction
NaOH+C2H5OH=C2H5ONa+H2O
is only slightly directed towards ethanol.
Glycerol is very slightly stronger acid than water, because while aliphatic chain of ethanol is electron donor, the other hydroxyl groups are electron withdrawing.
On the other hand, glycerol does have lower dielectric permittivity that water. At 25 degrees, I think 100 % water was 80 and glycerol was 41.
Lowering permittivity should weaken the dissociation of both water and glycerol.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
550
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
4K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • · Replies 19 ·
Replies
19
Views
12K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
5K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
9K