Does Resistance Affect Heating Effect in Electrical Circuits?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
2 replies · 5K views
Peter G.
Messages
439
Reaction score
0
I understand how the collisions between positive ions and electrons generate heat when a current runs through a wire. I, therefore understand that as temperature increases, collisions are more frequent, translating into a higher resistance. It then follows that, an increased resistance, due to the fact the electrons can't flow as freely, results in increased collisions and an increase in temperature? In other words, an increased resistance equals a greater heating effect? I ask this because, from my understanding, a large current leads to a heating effect due to more collisions but, doesn't resistance hinder the flow of electrons? I tested this once with a piece of wire. I made the wire very short (very low resistance) and when I turned on the power it was cut in half!

Any ideas?

Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Peter G. said:
I understand how the collisions between positive ions and electrons generate heat when a current runs through a wire. I, therefore understand that as temperature increases, collisions are more frequent, translating into a higher resistance. It then follows that, an increased resistance, due to the fact the electrons can't flow as freely, results in increased collisions and an increase in temperature? In other words, an increased resistance equals a greater heating effect? I ask this because, from my understanding, a large current leads to a heating effect due to more collisions but, doesn't resistance hinder the flow of electrons? I tested this once with a piece of wire. I made the wire very short (very low resistance) and when I turned on the power it was cut in half!

Any ideas?

Thanks!

You might be interested in Joule's calorimeter experiments for deriving the Joule's Heating Law. Google for it.
And, yes, increase in temperature means less average relaxation time and hence more resistance.
 
Cool! Will look for it. But I read somewhere that the greatest the resistance, the greater the heating effect. How, if a larger current triggers a large heating effect?