Dog domestication driven by complementary winter diets with proto-wolves

  • Thread starter BillTre
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Evolution
5 replies · 5K views · last reply
Science Advisor
Gold Member
Messages
2,862
Reaction score
12,777
TL;DR
New articles have been recently published on dog evolution.
They cover the origin of dogs from wolves, a dog rediscovered in the wild, and selection schemes that might have been in play during dog domestication.
New dog genomes from a variety of current dogs as well as many ancient dog genomes have recently revealed a lot about dog evolution.
Article in Science (possibly pay-walled).
News article in Science.
NY Times article.

Dog origins:
It was thought that there might have been two origins of dogs from wolves (in different locations, which then interbred).
Now, it is thought to have been only one origin of dogs from wolves (although some still argue this point).
There were five distinct dog lineages by 11,000 years ago.
These got scrambled around, due to dog and human migrations.
Map of dog ancestry across the world with pie charts at sampled locations and photos of breeds, plus three panels of maps showing dog migration routes over time in Europe, the Near East and East Asia.


Dog and human migrations were tracked through genome analysis of ancient dog and human genomes from different places.
Dogs and humans mostly moved in together, but exceptions were found. Perhaps trading dogs between non-migrating groups of people.
Composite figure of dog ancestry analysis: map of ancient dog sites across Eurasia, PCA and genetic drift scatter plots, schematic of gene flow models, and a population tree of dog lineages.


There has been minimal gene flow from wolves to dogs since domestication, but substantial dog to wolf gene flow occurred.
Presumably because people would not want half wolves around that might kill them or their children.
Figure 2 from a paper: left panel A shows an asymmetry test diagram of a wolf and dog ancestry tree; middle panel B shows dot-and-whisker plots of f4-statistics with coyote outgroup; right panel C shows dot plots and a quantile-quantile plot for a Xinjiang wolf against 66 dogs.


Differences between recently developed (European) dog strains are largely the result of breeders manipulating a small number of genes with strong effects.The New Guinea (or Highland) Singing Dog has been rediscovered in the wild.
It is closely related to the dingo, doesn't hang out that much with humans, and can climb trees.
200 or 300 have been kept in captivity.
Two reddish-tan dogs with upright ears standing on a gravel ground covered with grey stones; the dog in the foreground faces the camera and the other stands further back to the left.


A new hypothesis about the mutual adaptive advantages for humans and pre-dogs (wolves) leading to domestication has been published.
It provides a new rationale for domestication.
NY Times article.
Open access research article (Nature).
During winter humans would be killing and eating large animals. Their most important parts to eat were fatty. They could only eat so much of the protein without getting protein poisoning (from eating too much protein).
Dogs (due to their different digestive system) could eat almost exclusively protein, and got leftovers humans did not want.
Because the humans (during winter) were not really in competition for the same food (protein for dogs vs. greater fat content for people), cooperative behavior could come more easily (both were persistent (following prey for a long distances) pack hunters at the time).
Leading to a closer association between humans and dogs, and in the long run, greater human control of dog reproduction (domestication).
Naomi Sykes, a zoo-archaeologist at the University of Exeter in Britain, who reviewed the paper for publication, said she thought the researchers made two important points. “The first is their suggestion that there would have been minimal dietary competition between humans and wolves.” The second, she said, was that their hypothesis “flips the idea of domestication” to people feeding animals rather than raising them to eat.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970, Greg Bernhardt, Delta2 and 3 others
jedishrfu said:
Imagine if the dogs got the upperhand. We'd have the collars and get the treats without having to worry about much else.
The possibility of getting neutered isn't a pleasant thought. But the consequences of humping someone at will would be half expected.
 
jedishrfu said:
Imagine if the dogs got the upperhand. We'd have the collars and get the treats without having to worry about much else.
But, but, where does that leave cats?
 
Cats? Were first domesticated later than dogs. Probably in Egypt. Domestication "horizontally (i.e., East-West)" of many species of plants and animals happened sometimes as more of an ensemble affair. Example:
Grain crops and crude storage were open invitations to various rat and mouse species. As people who brought in grain crops learned about cats and their predatory abilities, the cats followed.

You can read about this in various texts on 'evolution under domestication', or get a really well presented plant/animal geography explanation in Jared Diamond's "Guns, Germs, and Steel" - aimed at non-Scientists.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BillTre and berkeman
jim mcnamara said:
Cats? Were first domesticated later than dogs. Probably in Egypt. Domestication "horizontally (i.e., East-West)" of many species of plants and animals happened sometimes as more of an ensemble affair. Example:
Grain crops and crude storage were open invitations to various rat and mouse species. As people who brought in grain crops learned about cats and their predatory abilities, the cats followed.

You can read about this in various texts on 'evolution under domestication', or get a really well presented plant/animal geography explanation in Jared Diamond's "Guns, Germs, and Steel" - aimed at non-Scientists.
Just checking you have this Jim

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3145761/

Also this important study by Russian scientists on domestication that was nearly stopped before it got started.

https://blogs.scientificamerican.co...tten-russian-experiment-in-fox-domestication/
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: BillTre and Bystander