Doing a compressed air survey on your plant

In summary, the conversation revolved around a compressed air survey being conducted for a plant in order to identify potential cost savings. The survey involves physically tracking the pipes and redrawing them, as there is a lack of control and overview due to previous expansions. The focus is on measuring any swings in demand and comparing theoretical need to current production. The conversation also touches on the possibility of using different piping materials for efficiency, upgrading equipment for energy efficiency, and seeking advice from compressor vendors and manuals. There is also a discussion on how to delegate responsibility for maintaining and monitoring the compressed air system.
  • #1
Scott Vidicik
10
0
Hello fellow PF-friends.

I'm in the works of doing a compressed air survey where we wish to look at the savings potential for our plant. As there's a lack of control and overview we're going back to the basics (which means I have to start from scratch). I'm physically tracking the largest pipes and redrawing as I go (it's a mess as no one has been in charge of expansions).

I feel that I've gotten most of them now, all down till one inch pipes -- is this enough for just getting the overview, or will I find that much of leekage and such are in the smallest joints, etc.?

We have four 36m3 compressors which run just about constant, and one 24m3 which regulates, and there's miles (km) of pipes.

I've gotten a printout of the power usuage for the compressors for the last year (by the hour) and plan to use this to measure any swings of demand (long term). Shimming trough I can already tell there's been a significant increase the last year (going from about 10 MWh to 13MWh per week) -- this seems strange to me.

It would also be interesting to figure out how large our theoretical need is and compare this to what we produce today, or at least do an estimation. Does anyone have advice on how to do this?

We do not have machinary who are big spenders (atleast not any who count for more than 5%) so how would we approuch this in a good way?


If anyone has done a compressed air survey on their plant and got advice on how to attack this problem it would be highly appricated.

Thanks a lot in advance! :)
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
Another thought that I've made is: What's the best way to monitor the compressed air on such a large plant?

I've come to realize that if there's ever gonne happen anything I need to delegate responsibility and make each division work on their pipes/equipement/etc. In order to do so we need to figure out how much each division is using.

Do I have to buy some expensive digital flowrate measuring equipment, and hook it up to each "mainpipe" to each division? I'm fairly certain this is the way to go, unless anyone has any objections..

If that's the case, where would you get this stuff?
 
  • #3
Welcome to PF, Scott.
There are a couple of guys here who can probably help you out significantly. Unfortunately, I'm not one of them. My only possible contribution would be to inquire as to whether or not you have investigated any efficiency difference between different piping materials. As in, would stainless steel save any losses over ABS (just a random example). Anyhow, as I said, there are some heavy-duty experts kicking around somewhere. They should get around to you before too long.
 
  • #4
A high efficiency motor might help you meet your targets especially if they are on all the time.
 
  • #5
Scott Vidicik said:
We have four 36m3 compressors ... and one 24m3 which regulates...

Do you get spare parts from the compressor vendor? Try asking them your questions, they may be able to help. Some will supply temporary flow instruments and provide lots of advice. If you're already doing business (eg, spare parts) then you can avoid the need for a fictional system upgrade to get their attention and some of their time.

Otherwise, look for copies of the books provided by Ingersoll-Rand, Atlas-Copco, etc. I seem to recall lots of good practical advice there.
 
  • #6
Danger said:
Welcome to PF, Scott.
There are a couple of guys here who can probably help you out significantly. Unfortunately, I'm not one of them. My only possible contribution would be to inquire as to whether or not you have investigated any efficiency difference between different piping materials. As in, would stainless steel save any losses over ABS (just a random example). Anyhow, as I said, there are some heavy-duty experts kicking around somewhere. They should get around to you before too long.
Thank you very much, sir :)

ty2nu said:
A high efficiency motor might help you meet your targets especially if they are on all the time.
You are probably correct, but at this time a redesign of the system isn't a option.
But yes, improvement of drives is an issue.

gmax137 said:
Do you get spare parts from the compressor vendor? Try asking them your questions, they may be able to help. Some will supply temporary flow instruments and provide lots of advice. If you're already doing business (eg, spare parts) then you can avoid the need for a fictional system upgrade to get their attention and some of their time.

Otherwise, look for copies of the books provided by Ingersoll-Rand, Atlas-Copco, etc. I seem to recall lots of good practical advice there.
Yes we do, and I too think it's a good idea. We have a service agreement with our provider (used to be Atlas-Copco, but my predecessor was not satisifed) and I will use them. Just want to get an overview, and know what options I got so I won't be too inclined to accept their product pushing.


The audit is all part of a energy saving program. I am aware that improving drives (high efficency motors, speed control), upgrading compressors, use sophisicated control systems, recovering waste heat, reducing frictional pressure loss (increasing pipe diameter), optimizing end use devices, and removing leeks are all options. But I need to sell these ideas to the econmics -- so I need to know what options are the most optimal. Currently that means the ones with the shortest pay-back time, and lowest investments.

I've come to the conclusion that doing a air-leek seek (some claim this to be up to 30%) on the system, and that's all good. But I need a way to measure the improvements, and a way to delegate responsibility to each division.
 

1. What is a compressed air survey?

A compressed air survey is a detailed evaluation of the compressed air system in a plant. It involves collecting data on the system's performance, identifying potential issues, and making recommendations for improvement.

2. Why is it important to do a compressed air survey?

A compressed air survey can help identify areas of inefficiency in the system, which can lead to cost savings and improved productivity. It can also help ensure that the system is operating safely and reliably.

3. How is a compressed air survey conducted?

A compressed air survey typically involves conducting measurements, such as flow rates and pressure levels, at various points in the system. This data is then analyzed to identify any issues and make recommendations for improvement.

4. How long does a compressed air survey take?

The duration of a compressed air survey can vary depending on the size and complexity of the plant's compressed air system. It can take anywhere from a few hours to several days to complete.

5. Can a compressed air survey be done by anyone or do you need a specialist?

It is recommended to have a specialist perform a compressed air survey, as they have the knowledge and expertise to accurately assess the system and make informed recommendations for improvement. However, with proper training and equipment, it can also be done by someone with a good understanding of compressed air systems.

Similar threads

  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • DIY Projects
2
Replies
36
Views
7K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
10
Views
20K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
10K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Mechanical Engineering
3
Replies
82
Views
23K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
13
Views
3K
  • Engineering and Comp Sci Homework Help
Replies
24
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
Replies
13
Views
13K
Back
Top